23 June 2017
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas




  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia


  • » 04/29/2004, 00.00

    spain - islam

    Muslims divided over request for use of Cathedral



    Cordoba (AsiaNews/IslamOnline) – "We don't need to ask for the Vatican's intercession (to pray in Cordoba Cathedral) since it is a historical site," Munir Al-Musiri of The Islamic Cultural Center of Madrid (ICCM) told IslamOnline. "This is nonsense, I myself have prayed there many times."  Some Muslims deny that they have need to seek permission from Rome to worship in the Roman Catholic Cathedral in Cordoba, the city which had been the heart of Moorish Spain in the eighth century, the church which once had been one of Islam's holiest mosques.

    On April 19th the Islamic Council of Spain lodged a formal request with the Vatican to allow Muslims to pray in the former mosque. "The request was very well received," Mansur Excudero, the Secretary of the Council had stated.

    Zakarias Maza, director of the Taqwa mosque in nearby Granada expressed, "We hope the Vatican will give a sign that it has a vision of openness and dialogue… Cordoba has been a symbol of the union of three cultures for centuries. Even now, Jews and Muslims live together with Christians in the neighborhood around the mosque."

    Local politicians also backed the move. Antonio Hurtado, a spokesman for the local Socialist party told El Mundo, "We hope to see Cordoba become a place for the meeting of the faiths."

    Yet Musiri stated he had no idea a national Islamic group besides the ICCM existed in Spain. He believes the request was brought forward by individuals who "were in no position to speak for the entire Muslim community in Spain."  Fearing that this type of individual initiative would spark a certain "Islamophobia" during today's sensitive times, Musiri cautioned, "It will play well in the hand of some people and western media, which could add fuel to the fire and say Muslims want to re-conquer Al-Andalus (Spain)."

    Some of Spain's Catholic's have been angered by the proposal that Muslims share their worship space. "Will Christians be able to pray in the mosques of Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Iran or Kuwait?" one Catholic demanded on a religious website.

    A member of the Islamic Council of Spain, Isabel Romero, stated her perspective of the motion. "In no way is this request about reclaiming our right, far less about any kind of re-conquest," she told a local newspaper. "Instead, we want to give our support to the universal character of this building."

    The Cathedral stands at the heart of a UNESCO heritage world site.

    On March 3rd, however, a different picture was painted, when as Sunday Mass barely concluded, participants of the Third International Congress of Moslem Woman attempted to perform a communal prayer before the mihrab, challenging staff that tried to impede the forbidden act of worship, actions that would most likely bring the death of any Christian attempting the same in a mosque in a Muslim country.

    Recently, a prominent Spanish Muslim, Abderrahman Muhammad Manan, wrote that the ancient mosque should be freed and that, "We Moslems cannot stand behind, saying that Islam is not stones or monuments.  To do so is to not give account of what things are in their essences, and in its essence Alhama is Islam in our land, as is Al-Andalus, Andalucia; it is the remembrance of a colonization, of a genocide, of an expulsion." Alhama and Andalucia are areas in Spain with much Islamic history.

    Bishop of Cordoba, Msgr. Juan Jose Asenjo, has made no official response to the request but affirmed that the diocese "must be very prudent" in responding to the petition of the Islamic Council.

     

     

     

     

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version










    See also

    29/04/2004 spain - islam
    Muslims seek to use Cathedral alongside Catholics


    29/04/2004 Spain - Islam
    Cordoba's Mosque-Cathedral (profile)


    29/04/2004 VATICAN - ISLAM
    Vatican says no to churches used as mosques
    An interview with Archbishop Michael Fitzgerald, president of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialog

    06/12/2006 VATICAN
    Pope: In mosque I prayed to the one God for all mankind
    In today’s general audience, Benedict XVI recalled his prayer in Istanbul, not foreseen but very meaningful, and he augured that secular Turkey will guarantee full religious freedom and become a bridge of friendship between East and West. From Istanbul, Bartholomew I said he was sure the apostolic journey would bear fruit for dialogue among Christians.

    10/08/2011 PAKISTAN
    Red Mosque imam ready for war to ‘talebanise’ Pakistan
    Mullah Abdul Aziz accuses the government of “corrupting the country” and inviting “the wrath of Allah”. He says he has 5,000 fighters ready to set up an Islamic state. In 2007, the Red Mosque was the scene of violent clashes between the military and extremists. Analysis and Christians are particularly concerned about the situation. For the latter, tomorrow will be a ‘black day’.



    Editor's choices

    RUSSA - VATICAN
    Vatican and Russian orthodox scholars debate history and Ostpolitik

    Vladimir Rozanskij

    The conference begins tomorrow and continues until June 21. Joint work was blocked in 2002 over allegations of "proselytism" against the Russian Catholic Church. Change of climate after the meeting between Francis and Kirill in Havana in 2016. Russians prefer to talk about common mission to the world rather than unity of the united Church in the first 10 centuries.

     


    LAOS - VATICAN
    The “strength of the Church is within the small churches”, says Laos’s first cardinal

    Weena Kowitwanij

    On 21 May, Pope Francis announced his nomination, a surprise for Laos’s 50,000- strong Catholic community. It is a “baby Church” that experiences the first proclamation and is turned towards Tribals and animists. "Some of the most serious problems are the shortage of personnel and the quality of education,” the prelate said. "Some people think that being a cardinal is an honour,” but for Mgr Mangkhanekhoun it means advising the pope on how to “solve problems.”


    AsiaNews IS ALSO A MONTHLY!

    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.
     

    SUBSCRIBE NOW

    News feed

    Canale RSScanale RSS 

    Add to Google









     

    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®