17 March 2018
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 12/11/2007, 00.00


    New plenary meeting (and little hope) in Holy See-Israel negotiations

    Joshua Lapide

    The Bilateral Commission meets tomorrow, followed the next day by a plenary session of both delegations. The Vatican has been waiting 14 years to see the Fundamental Accord implemented. Impatience is growing over unfulfilled promises.

    Tel Aviv (AsiaNews) – Anxiety, concern, low expectations and a bit of hope are the emotions that prevail on the eve of another meeting between the delegations of the Holy See and the Israeli government which should lead to the implementation of the Fundamental Accord. Signed in 1993 the latter must be complemented by juridical and economic agreements to come into effect.

    Tomorrow, 12 December, the Bilateral Permanent Working Commission meets at the Israeli Foreign Ministry. The next day the meeting should involve full delegations chaired by Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Majali Wahabi and Vatican Undersecretary for Relations with States, Mgr Pietro Parolin.

    Israeli Ambassador to the Holy See Oded Ben Hur said a few weeks ago that the Accord should be finalised by 13 December. But lately the Vatican side has shown increasing impatience. Mgr Pietro Sambi, nuncio in Washington (a former nuncio in Israel), and Mgr Antonio Franco, the current nuncio to Israel, have expressed their irritation to the international media at the unjustified delays which are undermining trust in the State of Israel and its promises.

    An internationally-binding Juridical Agreement was signed in 1997 but was never implemented in Israel. An Economic Agreement in accordance with the Fundamental Accord of 1993 has still not been signed.

    This agreement should apply in three areas: Church properties unfairly expropriated or under unfair easements; the services the Church provides to Israeli Jews and Arabs; and the confirmation of tax exemptions which the Church enjoyed before the establishment of the State of Israel and which the United Nations said had to be honoured by the Jewish state when it was created.

    In an interview with the Jerusalem Post last 21 November, Rabbi David Rosen, from the American Jewish Committee and who took part in the negotiations that led to the accord 14 years ago, said that the “Vatican is showing remarkable patience and understanding regarding commitments made by the State of Israel in the Fundamental Agreement, which were to be resolved within two years but which have still not been resolved.”

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    16/11/2007 VATICAN – ISRAEL
    Nuncio to Washington says Israel not keeping its promises to the Holy See
    Monsignor Sambi, who was the Vatican envoy to Israel until 2005, highlights the impasse in bilateral relations, due, he believes, to the fact that the Jewish state has failed in ten years to live up to the economic and fiscal commitments it made.

    09/03/2009 VATICAN – ISRAEL
    Pope coming as a pilgrim of peace, says nuncio
    A day after the official announcement Mgr Antonio Franco explains the motives and significance of Benedict XVI’s trip to the Holy Land. It is not a political move but an encouragement to overcome difficulties and find solutions to problems.

    15/06/2011 VATICAN-ISRAEL
    "Very significant progress" in negotiations between the Holy See and Israel
    According to a joint statement that relates the meeting of the Bilateral Standing Commission held yesterday at the Vatican. "Open, friendly and constructive atmosphere". Departure of Fr Jaeger, a member of the group for 19 years, until now Legal Adviser to the Holy See.

    13/12/2006 VATICAN - ISRAEL
    Holy See-Israel accords are elements of international law
    Bishops and Catholic experts explain and clarify the position of the Holy See in talks with Israel. The Church is not seeking “privileges” but only recognition of those rights that Israel itself has promised several times over to observe.

    27/03/2008 ISRAEL - VATICAN
    Israeli ministry contradicts itself: a Franciscan with a valid visa is turned away from Israel
    The Israeli interior ministry seems to be working at cross purposes: it issues visas, and then does not recognise them. That is entirely the fault of the "secretiveness" that shrouds the procedure and criteria for issuing visas. There is also the need for the accords with the Vatican to be put into effect at last, in order to have clear rules for visas for ecclesiastical personnel.

    Editor's choices

    Syrian Trappist nuns say Western powers and factional media fuel war propaganda

    In a written appeal, the religious systematically take apart the version of the conflict touted by governments, NGOs and international news organizations. In Ghouta east, jihadists attack the capital and use civilians as human shields. The Syrian government and people have a duty to defend themselves from external attacks. The conflict alone has undermined the coexistence between Christians and Muslims in the country.

    Xinjiang, crosses, domes, statues destroyed: the new 'Sinicized' Cultural Revolution

    Bernardo Cervellera

    Crosses removed from the domes and the tympanum of Yining Church as well as external decorations and crosses, and the Way of the Cross within the church. The same happened at the churches of Manas and Hutubi. The Cross represents "a foreign religious infiltration ". Prayer services forbidden even in private houses under the threat of arrests and re-education. Children and young people forbidden to enter churches. Religious revival frightens the Party.


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSSRSS channel 


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®