30 March 2017
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 05/22/2008, 00.00


    Church: no to bioethics law, it permits sale of human eggs

    Joseph Yun Li-sun

    The revisions to the draft law, approved by parliament, provide "expense reimbursement" for those who donate human eggs. Scorching commentary from the bishops' commission for bioethics, which speaks of "an enormous step backward". In the meantime, the "pioneer of cloning" announces: four cloned puppies in good health.

    Seoul (AsiaNews) - The South Korean Church has forcefully condemned the revisions approved by parliament to the law in bioethics, which permit the "reimbursement of expenses" for those who agree to participate in cloning experiments, and open the way to the selling of human eggs.  A document published by the bioethics commission of the Korean bishops' conference states: "The change to the law represents an enormous step backward in the field of research ethics".

    According to the head of the commission, Bishop Francis Xavier Ahn Myong-ok, what the new draft law permits is "not much different from trade in eggs.  The formula of 'reimbursement for expenses' is merely a form of hypocrisy that serves to conceal the true intention of the researchers". Fr Remigio Lee Dong-ik, secretary of the commission, is of the same opinion, and tells UCANews: "The Catholic Church opposes any research that involves destruction of human embryos. This is killing, the taking of human life, besides which it violates human dignity, especially women's rights".

    The law on bioethics was approved by the Korean government in January of 2005.  It prohibits human cloning for the purpose of reproduction, but permits research on embryos for medical treatments.  Last May 16, nonetheless, parliament approved the revisions to the text that permit the selling of eggs.  According to the South Korean health minister, the changes will be approved by the new president within 20 days, and will go into effect beginning next December.

    In the meantime, the "pioneer of human cloning" Hwang Woo-suk has announced that he has successfully cloned five puppies, from the cells of the deceased dog Missy, the pet of business magnate John Sperling.  According to the veterinarian, known for his falsified research on human cloning, "four of the puppies are in excellent health, and represent an enormous step forward in the field of embryo research". Hwang was prohibited by the government from working on human embryos, after his research on human cloning was discredited by the international scientific community.  After a short break, the researcher decided to return to the laboratory, but "only" to work on animal embryos.

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    14/05/2009 SOUTH KOREA
    Korean Church against Bioethics committee and embryonic stem cell research
    For the bishops this kind of research is “ruthless violence” which destroys “human life in the name of science.” The prelates reiterate their support for terminal patients and call for research on “adult stem cells” or cells from human skin.

    30/04/2009 SOUTH KOREA
    Seoul lifts ban on human stem cell research
    Researchers in South Korea’s capital can conduct human stem cell research if they respect four conditions. Only eggs from aborted foetuses can be used. Research on human stem cells had stopped three years ago in the wake of the scandal that swept the phoney pioneer of human cloning. South Korea is now following the lead of the United States.

    14/06/2005 SOUTH KOREA
    Embryonic stem cell research is an act against human dignity, says Korean Church

    01/08/2008 SOUTH KOREA
    Authorities deny Hwang Woo-suk the right to conduct research on human embryos
    Hwang Woo-suk is still on trial for violating bioethics laws and falsifying results of his scientific experiments.

    24/05/2005 South Korea
    Tailored cloning is immoral and dangerous to women's health
    Ethicists in South Korea challenge the operation. Professor Hwang's team did not tell eggs donors about the risks involved nor did it mention the eggs would be destroyed.

    Editor's choices

    Pope tells young people to remember the past, to have courage in the present and hope for the future

    The Message for the 32nd World Youth Day was issued today centred on “The ‘great things’ that the Almighty accomplished’.” In her meeting with Elizabeth, Mary becomes a model. The pontiff calls on young people to avoid being couch potatoes, safe and cosy, urges them to rediscover the relationship with seniors. The Church experience is not a flash mob. The future should be experienced in a constructive way, and “the institutions of marriage, consecrated life and priestly mission” should not be devalued.

    Fr. Moretti: The Little Sisters of Jesus, for 60 years " Afghan among Afghans"

    They have lived for 60 years at the service of the needy. They remained in Kabul under Soviet occupation, the Taliban control and the NATO bombing. Respected by all, even by the Taliban. This February their experience will end, according to Fr. Moretti "an example for us all."


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSScanale RSS 

    Add to Google


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®