22 August 2017
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  •    - Afghanistan
  •    - Bangladesh
  •    - Bhutan
  •    - India
  •    - Nepal
  •    - Pakistan
  •    - Sri Lanka
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 09/19/2009, 00.00


    Law against sectarian violence: Indian bishops, appreciate but with some doubts

    Nirmala Carvalho

    The parliament will be discussing a law to avoid the persecutions against the minorities. Episcopal Conference: “ a good start”, but “more power” is needed in the prevention. The bishops have encouraged meetings with other Christian communities and Muslim and Sikh exponents. They will present a memorandum to the government at the end of October.

    Delhi (AsiaNews) - Appreciation with some doubts. Is the opinion expressed by the Catholic church in India regarding the Communal Harmony Bill (CHB), that will be discussed in the parliament. This is a good starting point, but “more clauses” have to be added to ensure more power “in the prevention of religiously motivated violence”

    This week a Parliamentary commission is examining the bill which is an integration of the Communal Violence Bill proposed in 2005; it intends preventing new cases of violence against minorities, like those that  occurred last year  between August and September against the Christians in Orissa. The Commission will present the legislation for approval to the Parliament once they have finished.

    The Indian Episcopal Conference (CBCI) has started a number of gatherings with various Christian communities: the bishops have planned a special summit with exponents and activists of other minority communities (Muslim and Sikhs) in order to formulate a common answer to the law.

    Father Babu Joseph, spokesperson of the Indian Episcopal Conference, confirms to Asianews the churches attention  towards the law, which it defines as “an important step” in order to control “the cases of violence in the entire country” and as “a deterrent” to the fundamentalists. They ask for “more power” to the law, that amongst various aspects has the advantage of “preventing” the attacks rather than “taking measures”  retrospectively.

    Fr. Joseph explains that “the police will answer directly to the courts..not  to the ministers”, the potential outbreaks of violence will be “closely monitored” and if necessary, “special bodies” will be formed to ensure “impartial and just investigations”. Too often-  underlines the priest- we have witnessed in various parts of India a collusion between various ministers, in order to protect the guilty and favor the  repetition of the crime.”

    That’s why it is important to separate “the political and judicial establishment” and the that “who fails in his job of ensuring order and justice” assumes his “responsibilities”. This refers to the police and bodies of justice, that like in the case of Orissa, did little or nothing to protect the Christians from the attacks.

    One of the suggestions put forward by the Bishops was that the compensation for  the victims of violence be guaranteed by “the State” and not the “authors of the crime”. The prelates also ask “the intervention of the central government” in cases where the state government cannot handle the violence’s and a more protection of “every citizens” rights.

    And finally Fr. Joseph is in favor of the establishment of special courts that judge directly in case  of violence’s  with religious purposes; another “deterring “ element to prevent crimes. “In the last week of October- concludes the bishops spokesman- a consultation to discuss the law at a national level has been organized, after which we will write down a memorandum that will be presented to the Minister of Justice”.

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    27/05/2005 INDIA
    Christian clergyman disappears in Andhra Pradesh
    Hindu fundamentalists come under suspicion for the incident. The Archbishop of Hyderabad calls for state intervention. He says that extremists are working underground and fundamentalist spies and informers are penetrating Christian communities to collect information and plan attacks.

    18/10/2004 INDIA
    Congress wins in Maharashtra, India's economic heartland

    A victory by the secularist party is a good thing but now it should do more for the minorities, Mgr Fernandez said.

    17/03/2005 INDIA
    PM Singh tells bishops minority and Christian Dalit rights will be protected

    06/02/2006 INDIA
    Bishop Fernandez: they attack us because they don't know the essence of Christianity

    The Secretary of India's episcopal conference remarks on the recent wave of violence against Christians in India: extremists don't know that God is love, something that would leave them dumbfounded.  To advance their plans, they indoctrinate poor people with falsehoods.  Catholic activist. "a dangerous pattern" passes also through Maharashtra and Rajasathan.  Accusations against the BJP.

    24/02/2005 INDIA
    Hindu fundamentalists attack Christian meeting in Rajasthan
    The fundamentalists are coming up with new ways to stop Christians from meeting, says the Bishop of Ajmer-Jaipur. Muslims say they are Fascists backed by the government. Hindu groups say 2004 was a successful year in (forcibly) 'reconverting' people to Hinduism.

    Editor's choices

    Card. Parolin in Moscow: Ostpolitik conquers distrust

    Vladimir Rozanskij

    The theme is a meeting between Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill, not in Moscow, but in some holy place of the Christian East, or in Bari. An international conference on the future of Ukraine and Crimea. Commitment to Christians and Peace in the Middle East. 

    For Eastern Catholic patriarchs, the genocide of Christians is an affront to all humanity

    Fady Noun

    Afflicted by wars, emigration and insecurity, Christian communities have now become "a small flock" amid the indifference of the international community. Patriarchs appeal to Pope Francis and the international community. Catholics and Orthodox share the same problems. The end of Christians in the East would be "a shameful stigma for the whole 21st century".


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSScanale RSS 

    Add to Google


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®