2 September, 2014 AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook            

Help AsiaNews | About us | P.I.M.E. | | RssNewsletter | Mobile





mediazioni e arbitrati, risoluzione alternativa delle controversie e servizi di mediazione e arbitrato
e-mail this to a friend printable version


» 07/02/2007
CHINA – VATICAN
Subdued but predictable reactions in China to Pope’s letter
The government again reiterates its two pre-conditions for diplomatic dialogue (non interference in Chinese affairs and break with Taiwan), but unlike the 2000 martyr canonisation affair, this time it has taken soft approach. The underground Church rejoices, whilst the official Church, which is under an even tighter control, is moving cautiously.

Rome (AsiaNews) – The Chinese government is embarrassed and unhappy about the Pope’s letter to Chinese Catholics. Among the faithful in both the official and underground Church the letter caused a great deal of enthusiasm. Official bishops have not yet made any comment however.

In China reactions among Catholics and non Catholics to Benedict XVI’s letter to the clergy and the faithful have varied but were more or less as expected. There was much enthusiasm and a renewed sense of fidelity to the Holy See among official and underground Catholics. But official bishops have been careful because of the tight controls under which they operate.

A few hours after the publication of the Pope’s letter about “truth and love,” Church unity and the need for religious freedom protection, the Foreign Affairs Ministry in Beijing released a terse communiqué that, without taking into account what is for many one of the most beautiful letters ever sent by a Pope to the faithful in China, expressed hope that the letter would not create any more obstacles in the Sino-Vatican dialogue. The statement reiterated China’s two pre-conditions to the restoration of diplomatic relations, namely the “Vatican must sever its so-called diplomatic ties with Taiwan and recognize the People's Republic of China as the sole legitimate government representing the whole of China,” and promise that it will “never interfere in China's internal affairs, including in the name of religion.”

This in itself for some experts is a sign of modest progress. In the past Chinese reactions to Vatican initiatives were much harsher.

The canonisation in 2000 of Chinese martyrs is one example. At that time Beijing launched a violent campaign against the Vatican, including personal attacks against the Pope, arrests of underground bishops and forcing official bishops to toe the line.

The subdued albeit predictable response (the two pre-conditions have been repeated for the past 20 years) shows at least a certain government embarrassment vis-à-vis the Pontiff’s inalienable demands on Episcopal appointments and real religious freedom.

As a token of courtesy, the Holy See provided the Chinese government with a copy of the letter ten days before its publication.

For some observers a subdued reaction is evidence that the country’s leadership is divided between those who want to modernise it and those who want to maintain a Stalinist hold, including over the Church. In fact, China’s Foreign Affairs and Religious Affairs Ministries have already expressed different points of view in the past.

Whilst the government responded last Thursday and Friday to the publication of the papal letter in mild tones, the United Front Work Department of the Communist Party of China met most official bishops in Huairou, near Beijing, instructing them to keep calm about what the letter said.

Ye Xiaowen, director of the state Council's State Administration for Religious Affairs, was there. He supposedly addressed the participants telling them that “[w]e have served you with maotai, the best liquor in China. After drinking it, you no longer need foreign wine,” which is one way of reasserting the plan to set up an independent Chinese Catholic Church, something that the Pope cannot countenance since it is contrary to Catholic doctrine.

By contrast, there is a lot of rejoicing among believers in both the official and underground Church.

“They don’t want us to show our enthusiasm and our unity with the Pope,” a Beijing catholic told AsiaNews, but “we are happy about the letter and the Pope’s condemnation of the Patriotic association.”

Formally known as the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association (CPCA), this entity was created by Mao with the explicit goal of controlling China’s Catholic community. Many of its officials are not even Catholic.

Among the faithful issues like the family are important. Removing special prerogatives from (underground) bishops and priests is another and so is the suggestion to all bishops that they set up all the necessary diocesan structures that are typical of the Catholic Church like diocesan administrations and pastoral councils, etc.

Conversely, Liu Bainian, CPCA deputy chairman, said that his organisation would not distribute the letter.  This would make it difficult for the Church to do it on its own because religious publications need government authorisation. Liu noted that Catholics can download the text from internet but in recent days the Vatican website has not been easily accessible in China.

So far official bishops have not made any public comments about the letter, fearful perhaps of what the Pope’s categorical refusal to accept CPCA’s control of the Church might do.


e-mail this to a friend printable version

See also
03/30/2009 CHINA – VATICAN
Persecution in China as Vatican meeting on China opens
by Bernardo Cervellera
07/25/2007 CHINA
The Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association celebrates 50 years at a less than ideal moment
07/24/2007 CHINA – VATICAN
Cardinal Zen warns against confusion surrounding the Pope’s letter to Chinese Catholics
10/21/2010 CHINA - VATICAN
Card. Zen’s visit to Shanghai may be a trap set by Beijing
by Card. Joseph Zen Zekiun, sdb
12/09/2010 CHINA – VATICAN
Assembly elects new leadership, causing major harm to the Church
by Zhen Yuan
VATICAN
Blessed John Paul II and our mission
VATICAN
Pope John Paul II is blessed for his strong, generous, apostolic faith
VATICAN - ISLAM
John Paul II and the Muslims
PAKISTAN
Education, more than economy, antidote to "Talibanization" of Pakistan
PAKISTAN
Archbishop emeritus of Lahore: rethinking the curriculum, focusing on equal rights
PAKISTAN
Muslim journalist advocates public schools along Christian model
PAKISTAN
Paul Bhatti, a "mafia" prevents stability and better education
PAKISTAN
Education in Pakistan: the crisis in numbers (An overview)
VATICAN – MIDDLE EAST
The Synod to support the Churches of the Middle East and the universal mission, Pope says
ASIA
The example of Mother Teresa: science and wisdom for our time
VATICAN-CYPRUS-MIDDLE EAST
Pope: Synod to reinforce solidarity among Christians of the Middle East
VATICAN - MIDDLE EAST
Fr. Samir: Christians together, the small flock and hope in the Middle East
PHILIPPINES
Manila "virtual" pilgrimage to 7 churches to meditate on the sufferings of Christ
PAKISTAN
Easter in Pakistan where an "unshakable" faith is stronger than fear
CHINA
Catholics in Yunnan and Guizhou fear drought, fires this Easter
VATICAN
Pope: live Holy Week intensely, to conform our lives to Jesus
INDIA
Easter baptisms, a right and the life of the Church, Card Gracias says
VIETNAM
"Mission means bringing God’s love to all" says father Ngo Phuc Hau
VATICAN
Pope: Lent, a call to "turn our lives around"
PAKISTAN – UNITED NATIONS
Pakistan’s anti-blasphemy campaign at the UN minorities forum
PAKISTAN - EU
Blasphemy in Pakistan and the European Court’s attack on the crucifix
PAKISTAN
Islamabad asks for "suggestions" from Christians to repeal blasphemy law
PAKISTAN
Save Christians and Pakistan from the blasphemy law
CHINA
China celebrates its rosy future without dealing with the past or present
VATICAN
Pope: encyclical, even globalization in need of a soul
ISLAM – EGYPT – USA
Fr. Samir: Obama on Islam pleases, but there are some lies and silences
CHINA - HONG KONG
Card. Zen: 20 years on from Tiananmen, Deng is dead: it's time to change the Chinese dictatorship
HONG KONG – CHINA
Thousands march in Hong Kong to remember Tiananmen
CHINA - HONG KONG
Hong Kong trade unionist: China risks another Tiananmen
VATICAN – PALESTINE
Pope shows courage against being used, Palestinian leader says
VATICAN – PALESTINE
Walls are easily built, but sooner or later they fall, Pope says
VATICAN-PALESTINE
Palestinians have a right to a homeland, but must reject terrorism, says Pope
VATICAN-ISRAEL
Pope: friendship with Jews, dialogue with Islam and all together to work for peace
VATICAN – ISRAEL
Holocaust can never be denied, belittled or forgotten, Pope says
INDIA – HOLY LAND
Pope’s trip to the Holy Land helps peace and dialogue, says Indian Muslim scholar
VATICAN-ISRAEL
Pope speaks of Shoah, peace and two states for two peoples on arrival in Israel
VATICAN – JORDAN
Pope describes visit to Mosque “a splendid day”
VATICAN-JORDAN
Pope: believers reject the “corruption” of violence and “cultivate” reason
INDIA - VATICAN
Kashmir: Young converts from Islam pray for Benedict XVI
CHINA
Charter 08, a plea for human rights in China | complete text
INDIA – ITALY
Shame on India, Europe and the world
INDIA
Fr Edward, survivor of arson in Orissa: the Hindu radicals are terrorists
CHINA
As Beijing bids farewell to the world a brief assessment of the Olympic Games
CHINA
China gets the gold medal in human rights violations
CHINA
The false images of the Beijing Olympics
CHINA
Olympic Games open in Beijing
IRAQ – VATICAN – WYD
Iraqi WYD, so far from Sydney, so close to the Pope’s heart
VATICAN – WYD
Bear witness to Christ in a world weary of false promises, Pope tells young people at WYD
VATICAN - WYD
The new Pentecost of young people in Sydney
CHINA
World leaders at the Olympic-market
CHINA
Beijing ready for Olympics of suspicion and silence
ITALY – CHINA – VATICAN
More than 500 Chinese Catholics in Rome to pray for China with the Pope
MORATORIUM ON ABORTION - INDIA
Indian communist atheist, supports the moratorium on abortion
ISLAM - EGYPT
Hegazi Case: Is there a plan for the world’s conversion to Islam?
ISLAM - EGYPT
Hegazi case: Islam’s obsession with conversions
CHINA
Beijing 2008: intellectuals and activists publish letter on Olympic Games and human rights
CHINA
Investments and environmental disaster: the two faces of the Olympics
PHILIPPINES - ITALY
Fr. Zanchi: the kidnapping of Fr. Giancarlo has caused many to discover what a missionary is
VATICAN – TAIWAN – CHINA
China needs the Catholic Church, says Taiwan’s Ambassador Tou
CHINA – VATICAN
Pope’s letter is key to China’s development, says Mgr Li Jingfeng
IRAQ
Terrorists sack and occupy a convent in Baghdad
BRAZIL – VATICAN
Pope: Youth, do not waste your life; build a just and fraternal society
IRAQ
Chaldean Patriarch: Christians persecuted by Iraqi government and foreign troops
VATICAN – IRAQ
Holy See: international solidarity for Iraqi refugees
VATICAN - CHINA
Pope and Cardinals : Consensus on China
VATICAN - CHINA
The Pope prepares a letter to China’s Catholics
Beijing and the Vatican: small steps and religious freedom
IRAQ – ITALY – year of the eucharist
Terrorism seeks to take away life, the Eucharist gives it back, says Iraqi priest

Editor's choices
IRAQ-ITALY
"Adopt a Christian from Mosul," the thanks of the Patriarch Louis Sako; the concerns of the Bishop of Kurdistan
by Bernardo CervelleraThe head of the Chaldean Church is grateful for the AsiaNews campaign and hopes that "this chain of solidarity will reach far and wide”. Helping refugees to remain in Iraq. But many want to flee abroad. The bishop of Amadiyah where thousands of displaced people have found haven in churches and homes: We also help the Arabs (Muslims), and Yazidis, for free and without looking at our confessional differences.
ITALY - IRAQ
"Adopt a Christian from Mosul" to respond directly to Iraq's emergencyAsiaNews is launching a fundraiser to support Christians targeted by the Islamic State, thus responding to a request by the Patriarch of Baghdad and Pope Francis's urgent appeal "to guarantee all necessary assistance - especially the most urgently needed aid - to the great multitude of people who have been driven from their homes, whose fate depends entirely on the solidarity of others." More than 100,000 people have been forced to flee their homes leaving everything behind and now have nothing to live on. To help them, five euros a day are enough. The funds raised will be sent to the Patriarchate of Baghdad, which will distribute them according to the needs of each family.
CHINA - VATICAN
Wenzhou bishop and priests slam government's campaign against crosses and churches in Zhejiang
by Eugenia ZhangFor Mgr Vincent Zhu Weifang, from the official Church, the campaign of destruction is increasing social instability. It is real persecution against the Christian faith. The bishop apologises for failing to intervene sooner. He was hoping that the campaign would end quickly. Catholics and Protestants suffer injuries as they attempt to defend their sacred buildings. For priests in Wenzhou, the campaign is unfair and touches buildings that have all the right papers. Such "stupid acts" by the government are undermining social harmony.

Dossier
by Giulio Aleni / (a cura di) Gianni Criveller
pp. 176
by Lazzarotto Angelo S.
pp. 528
by Bernardo Cervellera
pp. 240
Copyright © 2003 AsiaNews C.F. 00889190153 All rights reserved. Content on this site is made available for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not reproduce, republish, sell or otherwise distribute the content or any modified or altered versions of it without the express written permission of the editor. Photos on AsiaNews.it are largely taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to their publication need only contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the photos.