23 January 2018
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 08/17/2017, 16.27


    The funerals of Mgr Xie Tingzhe and Mgr Li Jiantang show the government’s double standards

    Bernardo Cervellera

    The first, an underground bishop not recognised by the government, was cremated and hurriedly buried. The faithful and priests were forbidden to attend the funeral Mass, and taking pictures at the service was banned. The second, a bishop with the official Church and a political advisor to the Chinese parliament, was exposed for several days honoured and his funeral was open to concelebrants and the faithful.

    Rome (AsiaNews) – Rituals for the dead are a very important part of traditional Chinese culture, whose oldest religious aspect can be found in ancestor worship. However, China’s traditional culture has been overwhelmed more recently by communist ideology and a paranoia of power.

    This is best exemplified in the different orders issued by the authorities and the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association (CPCA) for the funeral of Mgr Paul Xie Tingzhe, bishop of Urumqi (Xinjiang), and that of Mgr Sylvester Li Jiantang, bishop of Taiyuan (Shanxi).

    The two died 13 hours apart: the first at 8.30 am on Monday, the second at 6 pm on Sunday. Their stories are very similar. Both spent decades in forced labour camps, but the former never accepted to join the CPCA, whilst the latter did, in good faith, even though he tried to be always faithful to the precepts of evangelisation.

    This difference has resulted in distinct funeral services. Mgr Xie was buried in a hurry without honours; Mgr Li was honoured in accordance with his rank.

    First of all, the two bodies were treated differently. Mgr Xie’s remains were exposed to the devotion of the faithful for only 24 hours. Those of Mgr Li were exposed for days with a memorial Mass held today, and a funeral on Saturday in his native village of Gong'ergou.

    Funeral services were also different. Two hours after Mgr Xie’s death, the Funeral Committee, prompted by local authorities, issued a statement in which it laid out exact instructions for the funeral. The bishop's body was not to be exposed after 15 August, it had to be cremated the following morning, the funeral Mass could not be longer than half an hour as was the burial ceremony in Urumqui’s Dongshan cemetery.

    The Funeral Committee also ordered that only one priest, Fr Wang Hong, celebrate the funeral, and that Fr Li Zheng lead the burial ceremony. Two other priests – Fr Zhang Xuemin and Fr Song Zunshen - could be present at Mass, but they were not allowed to concelebrate.

    The diocese’s 26 priests, all spiritual sons of the bishop who set up the Urumqi Church from nothing, were not allowed in the cathedral. All but three had to remain in their respective parish under police watch. What is more, not only taking pictures or making videos during the service was banned, but the faithful were not allowed to take part in the Mass.

    Yet during the two days of mourning, thousands of people, the bishop’s friends and ordinary Catholics, came to Urumqi. Unable to enter the cathedral, they filled Dongshan cemetery to show their respect to the deceased (pictures 1 and 2).

    During the burial ceremony, plainclothes policemen kept a watch over the faithful to see if they obeyed orders. “The authorities did everything to demean the bishop as a person and devalue his influence in society,” a source from Urumqi told AsiaNews.

    In contrast to Mgr Xie’s minimalist funeral, the bishop of Taiyuan was led on his last journey in a very solemn way. According to some reports, at least five to six thousand people came every day to honour the body in the cathedral. Rites and prayers were held every day. People were allowed to take pictures (pictures 3 and 4).

    A Mass was held today in the cathedral, concelebrated by a number of priests whilst the funeral before the burial in his native village will take place on Saturday.

    Bishop Li Jiantang is described as the "secretary of the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association in Shanxi Province," and as "a member of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference", a body that advises the National People's Congress, China’s parliament. This blend of religion and politics earned him solemn honours.

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    02/04/2005 vatican - china
    China: the Vatican denounces the arrest of bishop, priest and layperson

    Meanwhile in China, news on the Pope's condition disappear from Internet.

    21/11/2014 CHINA - VATICAN
    For Global Times, Beijing open on Vatican choosing bishops, closed on Patriotic Association
    Anonymous sources suggest Beijing could propose two names with the Vatican choosing one. Even Pope Benedict XVI called for an agreement with the government on episcopal appointments. The CCPA is however considered an important, untouchable "historic legacy". It is also a one of China's most Maoist and corrupt agencies involved in business dealings worth billions, spared so far, from Xi Jinping's anti-graft campaign.

    19/05/2009 VATICAN – CHINA
    Prayer in Naples for the Church in China as Chinese Catholics face difficulties in Sheshan
    The day of prayer dedicated by Benedict XVI is in its second year. At least 400 Chinese Catholics in Italy are expected to take part in a Mass presided by Naples archbishop, Cardinal Sepe. Again this year Chinese authorities are trying to contain participation by Catholics, official or underground, to the pilgrimage to Our Lady of Sheshan.

    24/11/2008 VIETNAM
    Meeting of Vietnamese "government" Catholics' committee ends in disaster
    The meeting, delayed for three years, was announced by the press, but the final account fails to mention the number of participants. The body has changed its name for the third time, but it continues to find no support among the faithful.

    09/12/2010 CHINA – VATICAN
    Assembly elects new leadership, causing major harm to the Church
    Ma Yinglin, an unlawfully ordained bishop, will head the Bishops’ Conference. Fang Xinyao, a bishop in communion with the Pope, will lead the Patriotic Association. Three unlawfully nominated bishops are in the new leadership. Catholics worry more ordinations without papal mandate will take place in the future. One priest thinks the government has deliberately caused chaos.

    Editor's choices

    The Vatican asks legitimate bishops to step aside in favour of illegitimate ones

    John Baptist Lin

    Last December, Mgr Peter Zhuang Jianjian of Shantou (Guangdong) was forced to go to Beijing where "a foreign prelate" from the Vatican asked him to leave his see to illicit bishop Joseph Huang Bingzhang. He had received the same request last October. Mgr Joseph Guo Xijin, ordinary bishop of Mindong, is expected to become the auxiliary or coadjutor of illicit Bishop Vincent Zhan Silu. Sinicizing the Chinese Church means supporting the principle of independence and follow the leadership of the Communist Party.

    Pope in Peru: Young people, the heart can’t be “photoshopped”, because that’s where real love is found

    At the Angelus in the Plaza de Armas, Pope Francis calls on young people to follow Jesus with all of themselves, without discouragement, in the example of St. Martin of Porres, the half-caste saint. Silent prayer for peace in the Republic of the Congo. To the bishops, the example of St. Turibius of Mogrovejo, an indefatigable evangelizer: "Today we would call him a 'street bishop'". To the contemplative religious the invitation to pray for the unity of the Peruvian Church.


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSSRSS channel 


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®