21 November, 2009 A A A | | |
Help AsiaNews | About us | P.I.M.E. |
go to front page




Voli Low Cost Roma
Voli Milano



China | Islam | Economy | Freedom of religion | Vatican
e-mail this to a friend printable version


» 12/18/2004 15:03
ISRAEL – PALESTINE – HOLY LAND
Uncertainty on Christmas Eve for the peoples and governments of Israel and Palestine
by Arieh Cohen
The Palestinian elections, the withdrawal of Barghouti's candidacy and the crisis of the Sharon government have increased the sense of impotence and insecurity in the two peoples. Our correspondent in Jerusalem gives an overview of the situation in the Holy Land on the eve of Christmas.

Jerusalem (AsiaNews) – Instability and insecurity define the current situation in the Holy Land. On the eve of the Palestinian presidential elections no one can predict the reactions of the Palestinian resistance still committed to the armed struggle.

On the Israeli side, the fate of the Sharon government remains uncertain after sections of his party expressed disapproval for his policies.

The reaction of Israel's extreme right is worrying because it is well-armed. Israel's secret services are concerned of possible attacks against Sharon's life or the Temple Mountain to stop the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza.

Sharon however remains confident and pledges that 2005 will be a turning point for peace between the two peoples.

The Palestinians

Palestinians are getting ready for their presidential elections scheduled for January 9, 2005. Mahmoud Abbas, also known as 'Abu Mazen' is expected to win. Currently, he is the successor of the late Yasser Arafat as chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). The post is important because the PLO represents the Palestinian people on the world stage.

Abu Mazen is seeking the presidency of the Palestinian National Authority (PNA), the quasi-state set up ten years ago in parts of the Occupied Territories after Israeli military authorities delegated substantial administrative responsibilities in accordance with the Oslo accords.

Arafat too held the two offices plus the chairmanship of Fatah, the PLO's main political party. Faruk Kaddoumi, an unreconstructed opponent of the Olso accords, is now Fatah's new chairman. Alone among Fatah's leaders, he has refused to return to the Occupied Territories preferring to stay in Tunisia where he serve as the PLO's 'Foreign Minister'.

Abu Mazen's victory seems certain, especially after the only serious challenger, Marwan Barghouti, pulled out. Surveys had showed Barghouti and Abu Mazen running neck and neck.

Barghouti has emerged as the anti-establishment candidate, popular among younger Palestinians and those who received little or no personal or economic benefits from the Olso accords.

Behind the scene, some observers say that Barghouti's absence makes the electoral less democratic since the outcome is predictable. Among both Palestinians and Israelis, many have not failed to compare how Israel and the US insisted on 'democracy' and 'transparency' in Palestinian politics only to be too happy to see the popular Barghouti excluded from the race.

It is true that Marwan Barghouti, head of the Tanzim armed militia and the al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigade, is serving five life sentences in Israel. But his supporters, who now must take a low profile, do not think that is an obstacle in and of itself.

Two of Israel's former Prime Ministers led organisations that carried out terrorist acts at the time of the British mandate in Palestine: the late Menachem Begin, former head of the Irgun and Yitzhak Shamir, a former leader of the  'Stern Gang' which he later turned into 'Lehi'—Lohamei Herut Israel—Fighters for the Freedom of Israel).

Nelson Mandela, leader of the African National Congress, was himself jailed only to be freed when the Afrikaners decided to talk peace.

More importantly, Barghouti remains one of the strongest supporters of peace with Israel in exchange for the Palestinian territories occupied in 1967.

Never the less, since Abu Mazen is the only effective candidate that is welcomed by both Israel and the US, it must be hoped that with him as PNA president Israel will return to the negotiating table to hammer out the long hoped-for deal that would bring to a close the bloody conflict in the Holy Land.

The Israelis

Right now, it is Israel that has a problem with its own government. Dumped by all its coalition partners, Prime Minister Sharon can count only on two thirds of his 40-strong parliamentary caucus (Likud holds 40 of the Knesset's 120 seats). The remaining Likud MKs oppose his decision to pull troops and settlers out of the Gaza Strip by 2005.

If the current negotiations with the Labour party and smaller religious parties do not lead to a new coalition government, elections with their unpredictable results are inevitable for the Spring and Summer 2005.

What's more, Sharon and his sons remain under police investigation for financial misdeed. Although he avoided trail on some allegations, the State Attorney's Office is still pursuing him on others. Should he be formally indicted, it is difficult to see how he could keep his post.

If he were to leave, a great and dangerous vacuum would be created in Israeli politics. All his likely successors in the Likud are less moderate and might cancel the withdrawal plan from the Gaza Strip.

The two peoples

But what views do Palestinians and Israelis 'share'?  Surveys show that most Palestinians and Israelis want peace based on mutual recognition. But everyone is convinced that popular support is not enough and that a clear and decisive intervention from the outside is needed.

The latest hope is in British Prime Minister Tony Blair's proposal to convene an international peace conference, proposal that was warmly welcomed by Palestinians, less so by the Israelis and Americans.

Some observers think that Sharon's plan to withdraw from Gaza (and perhaps from some northern parts of the West Bank) will be followed by a long and intense period of Israeli colonisation in other parts of the West Bank (the so-called settlement blocks US president Bush approved in his April 14 letter to Sharon). This would inevitably put peace negotiations off to an undetermined date.

In the end, everything seems unpredictable, hanging on a thread, everyone's state of mind dominated by inconsistency, uncertainty, unpredictability.

Still, as Fr David Jaeger, a Franciscan of the Holy Land, puts it, this is privileged moment for a believer to reaffirm his or her faith in the 'absolute future of humanity which is God incarnated in Jesus Christ'.

What better way to express on the eve of Christmas in 2004 Christians' profound faith in the Holy Land.  


e-mail this to a friend printable version

See also
01/10/2005 PALESTINE – ISRAEL – HOLY LAND
Abbas's win, an invitation and challenge to Israel
by Arieh Cohen
04/03/2005 ISRAEL – PALESTINE – HOLY LAND
The Pope was always close to the sufferings of the peoples of the Holy Land, says Patriarch Sabbah
12/20/2004 ISRAEL - PALESTINE
Israel to free 170 inmates in gesture of goodwill
02/08/2005 ISRAEL – PALESTINE – HOLY LAND
Sharm el-Sheikh summit, a positive and encouraging step, says Nuncio in Jerusalem
02/08/2005 ISRAEL – PALESTINE – HOLY LAND
Fasting as jihad for Sharon and Abbas, says Patriarch Sabbah

JORDAN - CHRISTMAS
A Christmas of lights and contrasts
PAKISTAN – CHRISTMAS
Christmas, a holiday that brings Christians and Muslims closer together
VATICAN
Let violence end, everywhere peace is needed, says the Pope
VATICAN
The bread of life was born tonight, says the Pope
HONG KONG - CHINA
Christmas fosters hope burdened by politicians' 'decadence', says Bishop Zen
SRI LANKA
Yes, to peace and justice; no to death penalty, says Colombo bishop
MALAYSIA
Jesus back in Christmas carols
ISRAEL – PALESTINE – VATICAN
Christmas, peace in the Holy Land, peace on earth
BANGLADESH
Christmas in the orphanage or how the joy of the season meets hope for the future
UZBEKISTAN
Christmas in Tashkent after the wounds of Soviet atheism
THAILAND
Buddhists and other non Christians will attend Christmas mass
PHILIPPINES
The essence of Christmas is God made flesh, says Archbishop Cruz
PHILIPPINES
Pre-dawn mass to celebrate the coming of Christ
INDIA
Gujarat Christians want a Christmas without violence
PAKISTAN
Christmas in an Islamic country: festivities, traditions and solidarity
ISRAEL - PALESTINE
Days that seem to announce peace, says Patriarch Michael Sabbah
IRAQ
We shall celebrate Christmas even amidst all the violence, Chaldean Patriarch says
SRI LANKA
Catholic church set on fire near Colombo
VATICAN
May the Christmas tree teach us to give ourselves, says the Pope
ISRAEL – PALESTINE
Israeli Christians to visit Bethlehem this Christmas
SOUTH KOREA
Christmas trees in a Buddhist temple to honour Jesus' birth
THAILAND
Christmas concert by Thai prisoners' band
CHINA
No more tickets to pay for midnight mass
INDONESIA
Indonesia orders security clamp down after terror warning
PALESTINE
Somber Christmas in Bethlehem after Arafat's death
MALAYSIA
Christmas without Jesus in Malaysia
China - vatican
Christmas Midnight Mass for a fee at the Beijing Cathedral
INDONESIA
Tight security ahead of Christmas season
VATICAN
The crèche is a sign of culture and faith, Pope says
IRAQ
Bearing witness to Christ at the peril of one's life, says Father Ragheed in Mosul
PALESTINE
Palestinian Christians fear their country might become an Islamic state
PALESTINE
Between old fears and new hopes, celebrating Advent in Bethlehem

Dossier

Editor's choices
CHINA - VATICAN
Underground bishop: I joined the Patriotic Association for the good of the Church
by Zhen Yuan
Mgr. An Shuxin says he was not pressured by the Vatican for his choice. In front of the division created in the diocese of Baoding, priests and experts are asking the Vatican and China to free the ordinary Bishop Su Zhimin, , in prison for the past 13 years.
PAKISTAN - EU
Blasphemy in Pakistan and the European Court’s attack on the crucifix
by Bernardo Cervellera
Launched today from Rome the European leg (France, Holland, Belgium, Germany) of a campaign to raise awareness in Church and society of the plight and oppression of minorities in Pakistan, particularly the Christian one, due to the blasphemy law. A most unusual unity of purpose joins Islamic fundamentalists and European relativists.
CHINA – VATICAN
In Hebei, underground bishop joins Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association
by Bernardo Cervellera
Mgr Francis An Shuxin spent ten years in police custody. Now he is free but still under surveillance, dragged around to meetings to show the correctness of the government’s religious policy. Three bishops remain in police custody. A priest is arrested whilst two are freed to join the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association. The Vatican is accused of ambiguities.

Copyright © 2003 AsiaNews C.F. 00889190153 All rights reserved. Content on this site is made available for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not reproduce, republish, sell or otherwise distribute the content or any modified or altered versions of it without the express written permission of the editor. Photos on AsiaNews.it are largely taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to their publication need only contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the photos.