Forty Forties: The “Orthodox Sharia” of ultra-traditionalist Russians

The movement that “escorts” the patriarch reflects desperate patriotism, driven primarily by the war and a cult-like devotion for Putin and Kirill. Its activists have gradually shifted their fight towards the perceived enemies of “traditional values” in culture and law.

by Stefano Caprio

During liturgical ceremonies, the seat of the Patriarch of Moscow, Kirill (Gundyayev), who turned 80 yesterday, an occasion marked with great solemnity, is invariably surrounded not only by security staff but also by burly men dressed in distinctive red-and-black uniforms, members of DSS, the Forty Forties movement (Dvizheniye Sorok Sorokov, Движение Сорок Сороков), set up in the early years of Kirill’s patriarchate for certain goals.

In the beginning, the DSS clashed with Muscovites over land in parks and public squares where it wanted to build churches. Today, however, the movement has taken an ideological turn, "curating the imagery" of religious processions and taking legal action.

Judging by the extensive network of foundations and charities established by the movement’s leader, Andrei Kormukhin, and his children, this "struggle for traditional values" has also proven to be a lucrative endeavour.

Putin-aligned oligarch Umar Kremlev, who recently helped pay for the wedding of Donald Trump Jr, established one of the foundations working with the DSS, as Novaya Gazeta reported in an investigation by Lera Furman.

Forty Forties leader Andrei Kormukhin is the movement’s public face. Most of its thousands of supporters (according to statistics provided by the leader) keep a low profile.

About 90 per cent of the content in the movement’s Telegram channel is Kormukhin’s own communications, featuring clips from his many reports and interviews, visits to various Russian regions, and meetings with influential figures.

Kormukhin describes himself as a composer, writing the music for several songs put out by his sister, Olga Kormukhina, an Honoured Artist of Russia and a Putin confidante, who is subject to sanctions by several countries for her active support of the invasion of Ukraine.

Andrei Kormukhin was born in Nizhny Novgorod in 1970, ten years after his sister. The family was not religious, but Kormukhin claims that, thanks to his grandmothers, he was baptised twice: once into the schismatic Old Believer Church and once into the Russian Orthodox Church.

The future leader of the patriarch’s guards began a career in the Komsomol and was on the verge of joining the Communist Party of the Soviet Union when the Soviet system collapsed at an inopportune moment.

Kormukhin remembers that time with nostalgia: “The Soviet project was far deeper than the superficial framework they are trying to impose on us today.”

Paradoxically, Kormukhin links the collapse of the USSR, an atheistic state, to the decline of Orthodoxy. “When the generation raised in the Orthodox faith, or by Orthodox parents, passed away, the Soviet Union collapsed.”

The DSS came into being in the wake of the media disaster that hit Kirill in 2012, the fourth year of his patriarchate.

At the time, the patriarch backed Putin’s return to the presidency for a third term, a move followed by a series of scandals and controversies surrounding his flat in a riverside residence near the Kremlin; the affair involving his Breguet watch, which his press office clumsily attempted to airbrush out of photographs; and, finally, the Pussy Riot "punk prayer" in the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour, when the patriarch personally demanded the harshest possible punishment for the participants.

Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin, a staunch conservative who headed the Moscow Patriarchate’s Department for Public Relations at the time, led the mobilisation of various radical, Orthodox-patriotic groups in support of the patriarch.

Andrei Kormukhin acknowledges that his movement was born as a response to "information attacks against the patriarch," and that its response was exceptionally harsh. It is no coincidence that the movement was initially named after Kormukhin’s own nickname, “The Hammer”.

Its founders included Russian boxing champion Vladimir Nosov and weightlifter Aleksandr Mikhailovich, with combat sambo wrestler Fedor Emelianenko and a dozen other decorated athletes cited as co-founders and leaders of various projects.

After the movement changed its name in 2014, the patriarch began referring to its militants as his “guards”, and he communicated regularly with Kormukhin.

“I really enjoy celebrating religious services surrounded by these volunteers,” Kirill admitted. “I affectionately call them my ‘guards’; I like looking at their faces and praying with them… these people do a great deal of good for the Church.”

In February 2015, on Kormukhin’s 45th birthday, the head of the Russian Orthodox Church personally congratulated the leader of the “guards” and gifted him an icon.

In Torfyanka, a small, pleasant park with a pond in northeastern Moscow, one of the most violent clashes between the DSS and other “Orthodox communities” took place.

In the mid-2010s, a wide range of political forces, from the Yabloko party to the Communist Party (KPRF), sided with local residents who were defending their green space against the construction of a new church, a DSS-backed project.

Communist lawmaker Valery Rashkin even sent an official request to the head of the FSB, in which he described the DSS as a neo-Nazi movement that was illegally exploiting its ties to the Russian Orthodox Church.

Oddly, complaints against the movement, even from prominent figures, have gone unanswered, a sign of its unique position in Russia’s current system.

Beyond Torfyanka, DSS “athletes” have clashed with Moscow residents in at least 14 other locations; Kormukhin himself has described his movement’s tactic as a form of “hybrid warfare”, linking his opponents to opposition to Putin.

The goal of this “hybrid war” is encapsulated in the movement’s very name: the term “Forty Forties” (Sorok Sorokov) traditionally refers to the many churches in medieval Moscow, something that Kormukhin interprets literally.

For him, the number of Russian Orthodox religious buildings in the Russian capital must be increased to 1,600 (40 x 40). There are currently only 1,232, and Patriarch Kirill has long been committed to this target.

Eventually, the DSS shifted its focus towards combating the enemies of “traditional values” in culture and law, taking part in 2017 in protests against the film Matilda by Aleksey Uchitel.

When a bill criminalising domestic violence was introduced in the State Duma in 2019, DSS and its allied groups launched a fierce battle against it, in defence of “parental authority” in accordance with what has been termed “Orthodox Sharia”.

The COVID-19 pandemic, with its enforced self-isolation, followed by the war in Ukraine, transformed the DSS from a direct-action movement (with a hint of a militant component) into a semi-virtual society of contentious patriots, a cardboard army.

Sometimes referred to as the Orthodox SS, these guards now focus their attention on prominent cultural figures whom the movement, likely with the blessing of its overseers, labels “enemies of Orthodoxy”.

In early 2020, Kormukhin and his associates targeted Ivan Urgant over a satirical cartoon depicting a Nativity scene, an incident that forced the television host to issue an apology.

Complaints followed against singer Philipp Kirkorov for dancing on a cross, rapper Morgenstern for a video featuring imagery of clergy, comedian Guram Demidov, singer Instasamka, attendees of a “nudist party”, and others.

In early 2023, Andrei Kormukhin made a high-profile but ultimately unsuccessful bid to set up a political movement called “For the Family!” The Ministry of Justice denied its registration on formal grounds, noting that some of the party’s founders had previously declared bankruptcy.

The current iteration of the DSS is a blend of desperate patriotism, driven primarily by the war and a cult-like devotion to Putin and Patriarch Kirill, and a cantankerous, litigious impulse.

In radical circles, the DSS has been overshadowed by the larger and more controversial Russian Community (Russkaya Obshchina, Русская община), an organisation with which the Orthodox Church has begun to collaborate more actively.

Now aging and marginalised, much like the elderly patriarch himself, the DSS is intensifying its efforts at self-promotion.

On the occasion of Putin’s birthday, Kormukhin and his associates fervently thanked the “supreme leader”, stating that “much of what Russian traditionalists could only dream of until recently has become state policy under Vladimir Putin...

“When Russia was asked to renounce its own identity and live according to the rules of a foreign world order, Putin said ‘no’, took responsibility for the country and its people, and defended Russia’s right to remain itself.”

In an interview, the DSS leader suggested that he would like to see Putin as a tsar and the founder of a new dynasty: “The people must vote for the tsar, and Putin is the only politician today who shares most of our values ​​and who will guarantee Russia’s stability and sovereignty.”

RUSSIAN WORLD IS THE ASIANEWS NEWSLETTER DEDICATED TO RUSSIA. WOULD YOU LIKE TO RECEIVE IT EVERY SATURDAY? TO SUBSCRIBE, CLICK HERE.

Sections

Asia Today
Ecclesia in Asia
Indian Mandala
Red Lanterns
The Gateway to the East
The Russian World
Road to Seoul

See also

  • The Failure of Russia’s “People’s Unity”

    A year ago, Putin established days dedicated to the "minor states" and the "languages ​​of the peoples" of Russia, intending to express the ideal of “sobornost”, the great, universal union that embodies the historical mission of Orthodox Russia. Yet today, rather than a "union of peoples”, what is increasingly proclaimed is a “division of Churches”.

  • Egyptian government, monks near deal over Saint Catherine’s Monastery

    Archbishop Symeon announced the community’s willingness to sign an agreement regarding land ownership and the safeguarding of monastic life at the complex, a site in the Sinai that has served as a Christian presence of great historical and religious significance since the 6th century, and which, according to tradition, is where Moses received the Tablets of the Law.

AsiaNews Weekly
News from Asia that matters

Subscribe to the newsletter to receive verified news, analysis and insights from Asian countries every week.

Subscribeto the newsletter
  • P.I.M.E. Centro Missionario
  • Agenzia Fides
  • P.I.M.E. Brasil
  • Radio Mondo
  • Mondo e Missione
  • P.I.M.E. U.S.A.
  • TV 2000