Deportation in modern day Russia

The Moscow Duma is openly discussing the possibility of relocating 200,000–300,000 citizens living in the ‘liberated’ territories of the Donbass – which are now uninhabitable – to the Far East or Siberia. This is in keeping with the Russian-Soviet system, which throughout its history has displaced vast numbers of people to suit its own needs.

by Vladimir Rozanskij

Moscow (AsiaNews) – The recent proposal, also discussed in the Moscow Duma, to resettle the inhabitants of the ‘new territories’ within the Russian heartland is evoking associations with the deportation of peoples during the Soviet era.

The artificial allocation, so to speak, of the workforce, the ‘construction projects of the century’, organised recruitment: all this is in the Russian-Soviet style, states Andrei Kolesnikov in Novaya Gazeta.

The Russian state has moved vast numbers of people according to its own needs, rather than out of arrogance, fantasy or notions of ‘security’, and naturally ‘bringing these fantasies to life required forced labour: railways cutting through the permafrost leading nowhere, a perpetually ‘unfinished’ style, a symbol of the state’s irrationality and pernicious arrogance”, comments Kolesnikov.

Even the idea of diverting the course of rivers – fortunately abandoned in the late 1980s – has suddenly resurfaced, and the desire to dictate people’s destinies manifests itself in the most unexpected circumstances: thus, the television presenter Sergei Solov’ev proposed relocating people from frontline regions under ‘normal’ conditions to the Russian hinterland, where ‘there is plenty of free, buildable land’ .

This idea brought to mind the plan to deport Soviet Jews, which emerged in the final months of Stalin’s regime.

There are no documents attesting to the preparation of such a plan, but the experience of deportation accumulated in the 1940s may have provided the impetus for such actions, and the anti-Semitic hysteria that broke out in the late 1940s and intensified in 1953 following the start of the ‘murderous doctors’ case, together with ‘popular’ demands fuelled by the authorities to resettle Jews in some location in the Far East, most likely prepared public opinion for a mass resettlement.

Feasibility studies have also been presented: resettlement today would need to be accompanied by the government’s purchase of new buildings to house citizens living in the ‘liberated’ territories of the Donbass—which are now unfit for habitation—and by the implementation of certain programmes such as ‘The Far Eastern Hectare’.

There is talk of 200,000–300,000 people who would be asked to leave their homes and set off with nothing but the clothes on their backs – presumably to cultivate this very ‘Far Eastern Hectare’, which, in terms of comfort, is a far cry from holiday resorts.

It is clear that Russian authorities throughout history have always been concerned with the development of underdeveloped lands; their colonisation in some places has remained incomplete, and human resources have always been needed to adapt these vast expanses to human life.

And it is all too easy to ‘imagine the movement of huge masses of people as if it were a video game’, suggests Kolesnikov, since in reality the military clashes themselves have become like video games for many, and the participants – whether they are armchair warriors or office workers – feel like players.

According to the Kremlin’s proposals for negotiations, a broad ‘buffer zone’ is to be established in Ukraine that will continue to expand, and a growing number of ‘historic lands’ will be transformed into resettlement zones in remote parts of Siberia and the Far East. The journalist concludes that “territories matter more than people, who can be ‘replaced’, just like the course of a river. All a person can do is flee from these grand schemes on their own little raft – provided they have one, of course”.

Sections

Asia Today
Ecclesia in Asia
Indian Mandala
The Gateway to the East
The Russian World
Red Lanterns

See also

  • Moscow, far from Central Asian concerns

    Russian news agencies ignored the C-6 summit in Kyrgyzstan, which showed participants’ willingness to protect their economic interests from Western sanctions and ensure the functioning of the Middle Corridor. Meanwhile, the dynastic nature of power is being legitimised.

  • The Russo-Ukrainian dispute over the Baptism of Rus’

    For several centuries, the Orthodox Church in Kyiv and Moscow dated the Baptism of Rus' to 1 August 988, the feast of the Merciful Saviour and the Most Holy Theotokos, the day in which water was to be blessed in memory of the “Source of the Dnieper”. The idea of ​​linking the holiday to the memory of Vladimir arose in the context of the ecclesiastical and political intrigues of 2008.

  • Pondering post-Putin Russia

    In his book *People Behind the Fence*, journalist Maksim Trudoljubov explains the different types of Russian citizenship, based on moral service and private property. He also explores how a post-Putin and post-war transition might be organised on the basis of these principles.

AsiaNews Weekly
News from Asia that matters

Subscribe to the newsletter to receive verified news, analysis and insights from Asian countries every week.

Subscribeto the newsletter
  • P.I.M.E. Centro Missionario
  • Agenzia Fides
  • P.I.M.E. Brasil
  • Radio Mondo
  • Mondo e Missione
  • P.I.M.E. U.S.A.
  • TV 2000