29 August, 2015 AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook            

Help AsiaNews | About us | P.I.M.E. | | RssNewsletter | Mobile






mediazioni e arbitrati, risoluzione alternativa delle controversie e servizi di mediazione e arbitrato

e-mail this to a friend printable version


» 07/12/2007
SOUTH KOREA
Supreme Court: until labour the foetus is not a human being
by Joseph Yun Li-sun
Shock sentence in South Korea: a foetus of 42 weeks, weighing over five kilo’s, “is not a human being”. A priest, professor of medicine at the Korean Catholic University, speaks of a “social defeat” for his nation

Seoul (AsiaNews) – Korea’s highest court ruled yesterday that an unborn child cannot be considered human until the moment the mother goes into labour, thus clearing a midwife of negligent homicide charges. The verdict has provoked bitter debate in the country while the catholic community speaks of “the shocking and deplorable verdict”.

According to Fr. Lee Dong-ik, professor of medicine at the Catholic University of Korea and a member of the Bioethics Committee at the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Korea, “Every country has slightly different legal grounds on when to consider an unborn a human being, but no country has such a definitive ruling that an unborn baby is not a human being”.

In 2001, the mother, visited a childbirth facility in Seoul and consulted with a midwife as the birth date approached, but she felt no labour pains. The date passed, and the midwife told the mother to wait for two weeks. While waiting, the fetus died of cerebral damage. A Caesarean section was performed to remove the 5.2-kilogram stillborn child. The prosecution pressed the negligent injury charge against the midwife because the mother underwent surgery only after the baby died. In the appeals trial, prosecutors added a new charge of negligent homicide. The Supreme Court upheld an appeals court acquittal of a midwife and rejected the prosecution’s argument that the midwife had committed negligent homicide because surgery was performed too late, ruling that the unborn baby was not a human being, thus no homicide took place.

The most controversial point of the sentence, which one judge defined as “very difficult”, is that in which the Court establishes that “even if caesarean surgery was possible the mother did not have labour pains, which is the beginning of childbirth, thus the unborn baby cannot be recognized as a human being,”.

For Fr. Lee, this sentence “is a social defeat: We are living in an era in which a 21-week unborn child can be saved with an incubator.  It is unacceptable to see a verdict where a 42-week unborn is not considered a human being”.

 


e-mail this to a friend printable version

See also
03/07/2007 INDIA
Mumbai judges: the foetus is a human being
by Nirmala Carvalho
09/09/2004 ASIA
Child illiteracy and child labour are the continent's main social ills
02/05/2005 SOUTH KOREA
Revise bioethics law, says theologian
06/23/2009 SOUTH KOREA
Seoul, doctors pull the plug on a woman in a coma. First case of "passive euthanasia"
03/13/2006 SOUTH KOREA
Catholic church petition against death penalty

Editor's choices
LEBANON
Muslims defend Christians’ freedom in Beirut DeclarationFreedom of religion, education and opinion are defended by quoting the Qur’ān, which is the basis for the rule of law, not a religious state. Lebanese Sunnis slam violence committed in the name of God. The full declaration is reprinted here.
LEBANON
Islamic Makassed launch doctrinal battle against Muslim extremism
by Fady NounOfficial reference point for Lebanon’s Sunnis approves a document entitled "Beirut Declaration on Religious Freedom". Speculation over whether Dar el-Fatwa will succeed in gradually regaining control of Islamic religious teaching in the nation’s mosques.
HONG KONG – CHINA
For Card Zen, removing crosses in Zhejiang is an insult to the faith of CatholicsHong Kong’s bishop emeritus has come to the conclusion that the campaign to dismantle crosses and religious buildings is part of a broader, nation-wide strategy, and constitutes regression in terms of the mainland's religious policy. Catholics and Protestants in Hong Kong now fear that it might happen to them. In Zhejiang, another 15 religious buildings are slated for destruction by 1 September.

Dossier

Copyright © 2003 AsiaNews C.F. 00889190153 All rights reserved. Content on this site is made available for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not reproduce, republish, sell or otherwise distribute the content or any modified or altered versions of it without the express written permission of the editor. Photos on AsiaNews.it are largely taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to their publication need only contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the photos.