1 August, 2015 AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook            

Help AsiaNews | About us | P.I.M.E. | | RssNewsletter | Mobile

mediazioni e arbitrati, risoluzione alternativa delle controversie e servizi di mediazione e arbitrato
e-mail this to a friend printable version

» 08/12/2011
A world authority not enough to tackle world’s crisis
by Bernardo Cervellera
Two years ago, national governments saved the banks. Now they appear to be the enemies of people’s well-being. The world’s financial system, once deemed the “culprit” in the crisis, now appears to have the final say, acting as its last, out of control, arbiter. This is threatening democracy and freedom. A world authority is needed, but one that is subject to national check and balances. What is especially called for is a conversion from a (single) standard based on material profit to one centred on global human development, as suggested in ‘Caritas in veritate’.

Rome (AsiaNews) – The world’s economic crisis is taking an odd turn. In addition to attacks against US debt, the possible downgrading of French banks, hits at Italian treasury bills, the deterioration of the Spanish economy and the implosion of the economies of Ireland, Portugal, Iceland and Greece, the current political crisis is going global, humiliating world leaders who are losing their grip on power to the point that they appear useless because of their incapacity to find solutions and stability.

It is all very curious because when the crisis began (with the collapse of US subprime mortgages), political leaders were seen as the “saviours” and financial and credit institutions as the “culprits”. At that time, some even called for the “political” control of the world’s financial system, which had destroyed wealth and caused havoc, betraying people’s confidence and showing no sense of social and moral responsibility.

Eventually, it became obvious that the political system was in fact a captive of the financial system. Central banks, like the US Federal Reserve, saved financial institutions, pouring freshly printed cash into them. The latter found salvation, but savers and families lost out as sovereign debts hit the roof.

This was especially true for the United States, but also to some extent for Europe, where doubts were raised about the usefulness of the European Union and the euro for national economies.

A year after the financial crisis of 2008-2009, financial institutions boasted of their “success”, proud of their managers’ benefits, even though ordinary people had to put up with unemployment, deprivation, job insecurity and poverty.

Europeans and Americans have become increasingly critical of their rulers, seen as incapable of stopping the economic decline and often unwilling (in Italy for example) to tighten their belts.

Things are not so rosy for China’s rulers as well. The recession in the United States and Europe is affecting China’s own outlook since its economy is export-driven and dependent on the aforementioned regions of the world. Beijing tried a stimulus package to change direction but ended up stocking inflation. In an attempt to raise average revenues (and spending), it has pushed business (including Chinese-owned) to sunnier climes, causing unemployment and social tensions.

As in the United States and Europe, China’s decision-makers have been criticised for their incapacity to manage their nation’s economy.

China, Europe and the United States are the driving forces of the world’s economy. If we add to their crises, the shocks of the ‘Arab Spring’ in the Middle East and North Africa, we see that almost the entire world (except for Kuwait and Scandinavia) suffers from a crisis that is as much political as it is economic.

Increasingly, people are calling for an international agency that would watch over national economies, check the value of currencies, and monitor financial movements.

The question is who would control such an agency? How would it be set up? The world already knows how the directors of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), World Bank (WB) and even the European Central Bank (BCE) are picked: on the basis of less than transparent criteria (with behind-the-scene involvement of political leaders, financial powerbrokers and lobbies), far from the real life of real people.

Everyone is aware of how the IMF and the WB looted Third World countries, advising them “for their own good” to privatise, sell off, and thin out the social safety net in order to bring them into the vortex of globalisation.

Unless we want a world political and economic world order (like a new emperor) ruling over the (restricted) lives of ordinary people, we must make sure that any new authority (putting aside for now the question of how it could be established) is rooted in democratic and national checks and balances. The demands that many have made for governments to be placed under some form of “trusteeship” on behalf of the world’s financial system could in fact end up throttling democracy and undermining freedom.

In his encyclical Caritas in veritate, published during the 2008-2009 crisis, Benedict XVI said, “In order not to produce a dangerous universal power of a tyrannical nature, the governance of globalization must be marked by subsidiarity, articulated into several layers and involving different levels that can work together [. . .] if it is not to infringe upon freedom and if it is to yield effective results in practice” (n. 57).

The “quality” of a new international agency is also important. Until now, the financial lobbies that are causing havoc in the world had no standard but balance sheets and profits at any cost. No one has shown any concern for unemployed Americans, or the hundreds of millions of Chinese treated like slaves, or the Middle Eastern crowds driven this or that way by the changing prices of grain . . . . to this, we must include the aid policies to poor countries whose attached strings include practices that are anti-population, pro-abortion and pro-sterilisation.

On this, Caritas in veritate has something to say, even if it might a voice in the desert, when it argues that finance “after its misuse, which wreaked such havoc on the real economy,” must go back to being “an instrument directed towards improved wealth creation and development” for people and peoples (n.65).

Regrettably, the crises that are now causing mayhem in the world show that the existing financial order based on material profit as its one governing standard will be “validated”, so that all nations will be turned into “debtors”.

Indeed, all this is true. People do prefer credit (and debts) to productivity and innovation. Creativity and learning are less important than selling useless or outdated objects. . . . Above all, people prefer a life of idleness to one of sacrifice and work.

All this means is that the world’s crisis cannot be solved by an ultimate sovereign authority empowered to manage the wealth of nations. What is necessary is a conversion to a new and more global model of development, where creativity and responsibility are in forefront.

e-mail this to a friend printable version

See also
09/20/2011 ASIA-EU-USA
Economic Crisis: a controlled demolition
by Maurizio d'Orlando
08/26/2009 PHILIPPINES
Cardinal Rosales: the global crisis the result of greed for profit
by Santosh Digal
03/18/2010 VATICAN
Pope: economic crisis opportunity to think of a more "human" development model
08/20/2009 SRI LANKA
‘Caritas in veritate’ shows the value of the Church’s social doctrine
by Reid Shelton Fernando
07/22/2009 ITALY
Encyclical: the person must be at the heart of economics
by Maurizio d’Orlando

Editor's choices
Unofficial catholic community of Wenzhou speak out against forced demolition of Crosses, whole diocese fasting
by Joseph YuanAfter 90-year-old Bishop Vincent Zhu Weifang of Wenzhou led 26 priests of the open Church community to protest against the government’s act to demolish Crosses, Coadjutor Bishop James Shao Zhumin of Wenzhou also led his priests to issue an open statement “Strongly demand a halt to demolish Crosses on all churches.
Wenzhou: 90-year-old bishop and 26 priests protest against cross demolitions
by Joseph YuanThis is not the first time that the old bishop and his priests speak out against the demolition campaign against crosses and churches, which has touched more than 400 buildings. During the protest, police tried to disperse the group, which sought to submit a petition. The faithful recite a Crown of the Divine Mercy is in support of the Chinese Church. In Lishui, churches are expected to be torn down by 31 August.
After nuclear deal, Israel ought to become Iran’s best ally
by Uri AvneryThis is the thesis of Uri Avnery, leader of Gush Shalom, a major supporter of peace between Israelis and Palestinians. According to the great statesman and peace activist, Iran only wants to be a regional power in the Islamic world, able to trade with everyone, inspired by a sophisticated experience that goes back thousands of years. Iran, which faces backward-looking Gulf monarchies and emirates, could be a great ally against Daesh. Meanwhile in Israel Netanyahu, politicians and the media continue to blunder.


Copyright © 2003 AsiaNews C.F. 00889190153 All rights reserved. Content on this site is made available for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not reproduce, republish, sell or otherwise distribute the content or any modified or altered versions of it without the express written permission of the editor. Photos on AsiaNews.it are largely taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to their publication need only contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the photos.