20 February 2018
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  •    - Brunei
  •    - Cambodia
  •    - East Timor
  •    - Indonesia
  •    - Laos
  •    - Malaysia
  •    - Myanmar
  •    - Philippines
  •    - Singapore
  •    - Thailand
  •    - Vietnam
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 02/01/2018, 14.37


    Civil society against forced conversion of minors

    With a historic ruling, the Federal Court states that both parents must consent to the change of religion. The Constitution declares that the religion of a person under the age of 18 must be decided by the parent or guardian. Appeal for a clause stating that the religion of a child "should remain the one with which they were raised before the conversion of one of the parents".

    Kuala Lumpur (AsiaNews / Agencies) - After a 14-month trial, on January 29, the highest Malaysian court rendered the unilateral conversion of the three sons of a Hindu mother, Indira Gandhi, null and void, establishing that both parents must give consent to the change of religion of a minor.

    This constitutes an important legal precedent for the nation. Still underage and without their consent or that of their mother, the three children had been converted to Islam in 2009 by their father, a few weeks after becoming a Muslim. The man then fled, taking his youngest daughter, of only nine months at the time. Mrs. Gandhi has not seen her since. The children are now 20, 19 and 9 years old.

    The High Court of Ipoh, capital of Perak State, had previously canceled the conversion, but the father, Mohd Riduan Abdullah, appealed. A legal battle ensued for custody, which civil courts assigned to Ms. Gandhi, while the Sharia courts sided with Riduan. In 2014, the police did not comply with the civil court order to arrest the man, citing the legal conflict as the reason for their refusal. Malaysia practices a two-track legal system with issues such as those relating to family and marriages falling under the jurisdiction of Islamic courts. However, cases like this have led to "gray" legal areas.

    The ruling was welcomed by local and international organizations, including UNICEF. "This decision is in line with the principle of 'best interests of the child', supported by the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child," says regional representative Marianne Clark-Hattingh. "Unilateral conversions eventually destroy families and the resulting custody battles are often long and painful for all concerned, especially the children themselves."

    However, the president of the Malaysian Muslim Lawyers' Association, Zainul Rijal Abu Bakar, says that the decision of the Federal Court is "very sad" and not consistent with previous deliberations on the matter. "However, we must accept this decision because it is taken by a competent court. The Muslim community will have to wait for another case to be heard, so this judgment will be put aside, "says Zainul Rijal Abu Bakar.

    Following the Federal Court's verdict, Malaysian Prime Minister Seri Najib Tun Razak said on January 30 that the government could consider changing the law to align it with the ruling. The Kuala Lumpur government hypothesis receives strong support from Malaysian moderates, lawyers and politicians. They consider it appropriate to reintroduce a specific article to the Law on Marriage and Divorce Reform (LRA). Clause 88A states that the religion of a child "must remain the one with which he was raised before the conversion of one of the parents" and that the child can, after having turned 18 and with the consent of father and mother, convert to Islam.

    In Malaysia the Constitution states that Islam is a state religion and 61.3% of the population declares itself Muslim. Article 12, paragraph 4 of the Charter states that the religion of a person under the age of 18 must be decided by their parent or guardian.

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    23/06/2006 MALAYSIA
    Prayer campaign for Lina Joy, the law does not allow her to convert to Christianity
    National Registration Department and Court of Appeal refused to accept her conversion. Federal Court is set to rule next week on her case.

    24/08/2009 MALAYSIA
    Caning of women suspended as act of "mercy" for Ramadan
    The woman had been sentenced to six lashes for having drunk beer in a nightclub. The sentence will be carried out at the end of the holy month of fasting and prayer. Malaysian majority and opposition keep silent on the matter so as not to lose the support of fundamentalist wing.

    01/06/2007 MALAYSIA
    A Muslim can renounce his faith, but only as set out by Sharia
    Malaysia’s Chief Justice explains while upholding the Federal Courts ruling on the Lina Joy case, the Christian convert forced to face an Islamic court judgement. The Premier Badawi excludes that political pressure influenced judges, but admits the governments need to deal with the issue of non Muslim citizens and Islamic Courts.

    30/03/2016 18:45:00 MALAYSIA
    Sarawak: forcibly converted to Islam as a child, man can return to Christianity

    The Kuching High Court rules in favour Roneey Anak Rebit, who was registered as a Muslim, citing Article 11 of the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of religion. For Catholic priest, he was able to return to Christianity "because he had never practiced Islam and his life had nothing to do with that religion.” For others, “changing religion is almost impossible."

    14/03/2007 MALAYSIA
    Woman battles against the “forced” conversion of her children to Islam
    Her husband, recently converted to Islam, petitions Islamic Courts for divorce; his wife, a Muslim of Indian origin, wants their case heard before a civil court and asks for custody of their two children.

    Editor's choices

    The tears of Chinese bishops. A portrait of Msgr. Zhuang, bishop of Shantou

    Padre Pietro

    A priest of the official Church, recalls the 88 year old bishop that the Vatican wants to replace with an illegitimate bishop, to please the regime. Mons. Zhuang Jianjian became an underground bishop at the behest of the Vatican in 2006. Card. Zen and Msgr. Zhuang, image of the faithful Church, "which provokes an immense sadness and a sense of impotence". The hopes of card. Parolin to console "the past and present sufferings of Chinese Catholics".

    Card. Zen on the bishops of Shantou and Mindong

    Card. Joseph Zen

    The bishop emeritus of Hong Kong confirms the information published in recent days by AsiaNews and reveals details of his conversation with Pope Francis on these topics: "Do not create another Mindszenty case", the primate of Hungary whom the Vatican forced to leave the country, appointing a successor in Budapest, at the will of the communist government of the time. 


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSSRSS channel 


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®