23 March 2018
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 07/18/2013, 00.00


    Narendra Modi must be stopped or he will destroy democracy in India

    p. Cedric Prakash sj

    For the director of the Prashant Jesuit Centre for Human Rights, Justice and Peace, Gujarat's chief minister is " becoming more and more rabid and perhaps even unstable". If he is not stopped before the next elections, "it may truly be the end of India as a secular country".

    Ahmedabad (AsiaNews) - Narendra Modi, chief minister of Gujarat, is a danger to India's minorities and a threat to secularism in the country, this according to by Fr Cedric Prakash, director of the Prashant Jesuit Centre for Human Rights, Justice and Peace, who spoke out after  the politician said he felt sad "as when you run over a puppy" in relation to the 2002 Gujarat massacres. A prominent member of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), a Hindu nationalist party, with his constant "controversial, vulgar and extremist comments," Modi showed that for him "the minorities of the country and particularly the Muslims have no part in his scheme of things." Here are Fr Prakash's reflections to AsiaNews.

    Narendra Modi, the Chief Minister of Gujarat, has done it again! He continues to prove that he not merely suffers from a 'foot-in-the-mouth' disease but that he is becoming more and more rabid and perhaps even unstable.

    After his "puppy" metaphor in the context of the Gujarat Carnage of 2002 in an interview to a foreign news agency 'Reuters', he has now lambasted the Congress party saying that "whenever they are faced with a crisis they wear the burqa of secularism and hide in a bunker"; this was at a public rally in Pune on July 14th.

    This serious gaffe by Modi (which has naturally provoked a national outrage and condemnation) is not about whether the Congress party has been living up to the challenges or not, but of the nature of his expression.

    The 'burqa' is an enveloping outer garment worn by women in some Islamic traditions to cover their bodies in public. Many Muslims believe that the Quran, their Holy Book require that men and women dress modestly in public. 

    By using the word burqa in a derogatory manner, Modi has once again made his intentions very clear: the minorities of the country and particularly the Muslims have no part in his scheme of things.

    Further, by communalizing and trivializing 'secularism', Modi once again demonstrates that he clearly does not believe in the Constitution of India.  The word 'secular' (even if it is not practised by many) is a concept very sacred to the vast majority in this diverse country.

    The 'burqa of secularism' therefore is not merely about a choice of words or the mental stability of someone who by putting his foot into the mouth evokes a sadistic pleasure among a section of the country. It is far more dangerous! It is about the mind-set of someone who is desperately trying to project himself as a possible leader of the country. The phrase is reflective of a deep hatred towards the Muslims (and surely of all minorities) and the fact that he would never want India to continue as a secular nation. In the above-mentioned interview which he gave to Reuters, he very boldly proclaimed that he is a 'Hindu nationalist'.

    If one goes by the core ideology of the Sangh Parivar whose sole desire is to make of India a 'Hindu State', Modi's utterances are right on track. While most thinking Indians (including some of his own party men) have objected to his divisive, derogatory and polarizing remarks, one should also take note that if Modi is not reined in effectively at this juncture or defeated comprehensively by the electorate, it may truly be the end of India as a secular country!

    (Nirmala Carvalho contributed to this article)

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    20/07/2017 10:05:00 CHINA - INDIA
    Modi’s Hindu nationalism could trigger another war, the Global Times says

    A belligerent editorial in the Chinese Communist Party newspaper clarifies Beijing's position. Tensions have reignited between China and India near the border with Bhutan, on the Doklam plateau claimed by China. The armies have been facing off for about a month. India feels still surrounded.

    22/04/2014 INDIA
    For Indian Jesuit, Narendra Modi is vindictive and a threat to India's minorities
    The director of the Prashant Human Rights Centre recounts three incidents involving the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), for whom Modi is running as candidate for the prime minister's office. For Fr Prakash, the pledge to introduce anti-conversion laws and threats against the Muslim community "show the fascist agenda" of the BJP. However, we must have hope; "the struggle will continue indeed, even if the signs are ominous."

    12/05/2014 INDIA
    For Indian activist, Narendra Modi will not win in Varanasi
    Lenin Raghuvanshi, an activist for the rights of Dalits and weaker, makes the prediction to AsiaNews with regards to voting in Uttar Pradesh's "holy city" where the last phase in India's staggered parliamentary election is underway. Although public opinion polls give the Hindu nationalist leader an edge, "The Hindu religion is fighting fundamentalism."

    29/03/2014 INDIA
    Indian activist: Narendra Modi and Arwind Kejriwal, as dangerous as "Hitler and Mussolini"
    For Lenin Raghuvanshi, activist for development of Dalits , Modi (BJP Hindu nationalist party ) and Kejriwal (AAP, anti-corruption party) " are trying to destroy the pluralistic fabric of Varanasi from different political positions". The two leaders have chosen to run for election in city.

    02/05/2017 18:04:00 INDIA
    Cow protectors lynch two Muslims in Assam. For activist, this is hatred against Islam

    The victims had been accused of planning to steal cattle. Two people have been arrested on murder charges. Episodes of intolerance towards minorities have increased with the rise of Hindu nationalists. At least, ten Muslims have been killed since 2015.

    Editor's choices

    Putin's victory seen from West and East

    Xi Jinping sent a highly congratulatory message. Japan and Germany issued polite words. The Observatory for Security and Cooperation in Europe criticised restrictions on fundamental freedoms. Tensions with Britain remain over the ex-spy poisoning. For Chinese scholar, as the West continues to attack Russia and China, the two will move closer.

    NPC: silence on constitutional amendment, scripted media coverage

    John Ai

    Spokespeople provide scripted answers to scripted questions. Various “foreign” media are funded by China as propaganda tools. The end of term limits for Xi Jinping is the will of the people even though the people did not know about it.


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSSRSS channel 


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®