18 November 2017
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 04/16/2008, 00.00


    Moscow patriarch responds to 138 Muslim scholars

    Maria Anikina

    In a letter published on the Moscow Patriarchate website, Aleksij II lays out the ground for a possible dialogue with Islam, namely the need to face common challenges that require joining forces. At the same time he insists that in any exchange the identity of each participant must be respected so as to avoid the danger of syncretism.

    Moscow (AsiaNews) – The Russian Orthodox Church has responded to the letter 138 Muslim scholars wrote to Christian leaders. The text of the response was published on the website of the Patriarchate of Moscow and is signed by Patriarch Aleksij II himself.

    In this letter the Russian patriarch expressed his gratitude for the scholars’ initiative. He agreed that Christians and Muslims have similar goals and that they can join forces to achieve these aims.

    “Today Christianity and Islam do a quite important thing—they remind mankind of God’s existence and of the spiritual dimension of man and the world,” Patriarch Aleksij II wrote.

    At the same time ‘[t]his joining will not happen if there is no clarification in understanding religious values of each other. That is why I greet the striving of the Muslim community to begin sincere and open dialogue with representatives of Christian Churches on a serious scientific and intellectual level,” he said.

    In describing points common to both religions the Patriarch noted that the commandment to love one’s God and one’s neighbour brought them closer.

    For Alexsij II each point in Christian and Muslim teachings must be seen as deeply connected with “its unique place in the whole theological system”.

    Yet he added that any inter-faith dialogue must respect the identity of each participant to avoid the danger of syncretism.

    A possible dialogue can be built at two levels. On “a doctrinal level it could touch such important questions like God, man and the world;” at a more practical level, it could be realised in “defending the role of religion in social life, fighting xenophobia and intolerance, [. . .] and promoting common peaceful initiatives”.

    The current “doctrinal dialogue” between Islam and Russian Orthodoxy is “more active” according to Aleksij II. Common challenges that no single religion can face alone are among its reasons, challenges like an “anti-religious world view’ that tends “to subordinate all spheres of social life” to universality, and attempts to install a “new morality” that contradicts the “moral norms supported by traditional religions”.

    The head of the Russian Orthodox Church lamented the fact that the two religions had “enemies” bent on causing “a clash between Christians and Muslims.”

    Finally he stressed that Russia is a “rare multi-religious and multinational state” that can serve as an example for the co-existence between Islam and Christianity.

    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    11/10/2007 ISLAM – VATICAN
    We have “a Common Word,” say 138 Muslim scholars in a letter to the Pope
    The letter, which was signed by Sunni and Shia scholars from almost every Muslim country, is addressed to all Christian leaders. “If Muslims and Christians are not at peace, the world cannot be at peace.”

    28/03/2008 RUSSIA
    Moscow Patriarchate to “monitor” Catholic orphanages
    The decision comes at the end of a meeting by a joint working group on problems between the two Churches. The Patriarchate wants to keep an eye on Orthodox children who live in Catholic institutions. This however has been the rule for years. Once again silence prevails on other, more important issues.

    27/02/2008 ISLAM
    Muslim scholars’ letter to the “Jewish community”
    Some Muslim intelelctuals write to the world’s Jewish community as others did back in October to Christian leaders. Signatories emphasise their commitment to improving and increasing mutual respect and understanding with members of other religions.

    21/03/2013 PAKISTAN
    Pakistani Muslims: solidarity with Christians, victims of Lahore arson attack
    Over a thousand people attended an inter- religious conference. Hindu and Sikh leaders also present, as well as Saudi Muslim personalities. Appeal to Islamabad to punish those responsible for the attacks. Government of Punjab applauded for its support. Invitations to harmony and combat extremism.

    20/09/2010 RUSSIA
    Moscow, Muslims may end up praying in churches
    The mufti of the capital warns: lack of mosques, we would not want to end up celebrating in churches. The Russian Orthodox Patriarchate says it is "happy to accommodate our Muslim brothers." But these are superficial statements to content the government's policy of tolerance. Neither community is planning to arrive at such "extreme" solutions.

    Editor's choices

    Mass for a deceased underground priest. Card. Zen asks for God ‘s grace to save the Church in China and the Holy See from the 'precipice'

    Li Yuan

    Fr. Wei Heping, 41, died in mysterious circumstances, his body dumped in a river in Taiyuan (Shanxi). For the police claim he committed suicide. Family members are not allowed to even see the autopsy report. For Card. Zen the Holy See (which "is not necessarily the Pope") seeks a compromise at all costs with the Chinese government, risking "to sell out the faithful Church". Justice and Peace publish a booklet about Fr. Wei, not to forget.

    Pope: No more war, its only fruit is death, 'our self-destruction'

    Marking the Feast of All Souls, Francis celebrated Mass at the American Cemetery in Nettuno. "When so many times in history men think of a war, they are convinced of bringing a new world, they are convinced of making a 'spring'. It ends in a winter, ugly, cruel, with the reign of terror and death."


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSScanale RSS 

    Add to Google


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®