12/05/2008, 00.00
Send to a friend

Alexy II, hope and obstacle in dialogue between Catholics and Orthodox

by Franco Pisano
The Vatican is paying homage to the work of the patriarch, who "in a period of great change" made the Russian Orthodox Church capable of "facing the challenges of transition from the Soviet era to the present one," and is recalling his "personal commitment" to relations with Catholics.

Vatican City (AsiaNews) - Alexy II guided the Russian Orthodox Church "in a period of great change," making it capable of "facing the challenges of transition from the Soviet era to the present one," and his "personal commitment to promoting relations with the Catholic Church, in spite of the difficulties and tensions that have emerged from time to time," "was never brought into question." This is how the Vatican, through Cardinal Walter Kasper, is commemorating today the death of the patriarch of Moscow, joining "the hierarchy and faithful of the Russian Orthodox Church in commending Patriarch Alexy to the eternal love of the Heavenly Father."

A brief note from the pontifical council for the promotion of Christian unity contains the Vatican's first comment on the death of a man who since 1990, when he was elected, represented for Catholics both a hope and an obstacle. Following the fall of the Berlin Wall, in fact, the Catholic Church placed great hope in the possibility of reconciliation with the Russian Orthodox, made problematic in the past by the question of the "Uniates," Eastern rite Catholics. Harshly persecuted under the Stalinist regime, especially in Ukraine, to the point of forced dissolution and absorption by the patriarchate, with the fall of communism they demanded the restitution of what had been taken from them. This led to accusations of violence, and especially of proselytism.

In a "Letter to the bishops of the European continent on relations between Catholics and Orthodox in the new situation of Central and Eastern Europe" in May of 1991, John Paul II wrote that "dialogue still remains the best instrument for embarking upon a fraternal exchange which aims at settling the issue in a spirit of justice, charity and forgiveness. Brothers who once shared the same sufferings and trials ought not to oppose one another today, but should look together at the future opening before them with promising signs of hope."

From Moscow, in fact, there have been serious and increasing accusations of proselytism, leading to a decade-long shutdown in the work of the mixed Catholic and Orthodox commission. Moscow also refused to take part in the synod that in November of 1991 was focused on Christianity in a changing Europe.

The Vatican has never stopped trying to heal this rift. There have been encounters, commissions, exchanges of visits and of gifts, but essentially, during the entire pontificate of John Paul II, nothing changed. The 1995 encyclical "Ut Unum Sint," which among other things called for the Churches and their theologians to undertake a dialogue with him on how the pope could exercise his role in a way acceptable for all, had no effect. Nor was there any effect by the gift to Russia of the Mother of God of Kazan, possibly the most venerated icon of the country.

On the contrary. Partly at the request of the patriarchate, there was a series of laws, under Yeltsin and also with Putin, denying Catholics the status of an historical religion in Russia, and severely limiting their religious freedom. Attempts to organize a meeting between Alexy and John Paul II never came to a conclusion, although the pope said that he was willing to do this "anywhere."

On a positive note, there were exchanges of greetings, which sometimes were not merely formal, between the patriarch of Moscow and the pope, and a few visits to the Vatican by representatives of Russian Orthodoxy.

With the pontificate of Benedict XVI, things seem to have improved. There have been a few "gestures," leading to speculation about the possibility of a meeting between Benedict XVI and Alexy next year. Now everything will depend on who the new patriarch will be, and on the agreements that will be made at the moment of his selection. Without forgetting the significance that the "opinions" of the Russian political world have for the patriarchate.

Send to a friend
Printable version
See also
Alexy II, the contradictions of Orthodoxy and of Russia
Alexy II: pope expresses condolences
Cardinal Kasper in Russia for "deeper" understanding of Orthodoxy
Extraordinary session of holy synod for post-Alexy II
Pope talks about the Middle East, the Holy Land and the food crisis with Bush


Subscribe to Asia News updates or change your preferences

Subscribe now
“L’Asia: ecco il nostro comune compito per il terzo millennio!” - Giovanni Paolo II, da “Alzatevi, andiamo”