19 January 2018
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • » 07/12/2014, 00.00


    For Sepang Muslim MP, Catholic rights violated in Allah controversy

    Mohamed Hanipa Maidin demands justice for ‘The Herald’ and Malaysia’s Christian community, which has been under attack for some time. The decision to turn down a request for leave to appeal is against the Constitution because the case touches the public interest and raises an important constitutional question. Wondering about the “actual meaning of religious freedom" in Malaysia, he reiterated that Catholics did not violate any rule or principle.

    Kuala Lumpur (AsiaNews) - "I was me upset with the decision of the Federal Court refusing leave for The Herald to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal. As a lawyer, I find the decision weird. As a Muslim, I am of the view that justice was not done to The Herald. [. . .] The Federal Court should have" allowed the paper "the leave to appeal," said Mohamed Hanipa Maidin, a Muslim lawmaker from  of the District of Sepang, in his comments published by the Catholic weekly The Herald.

    An "appeal to the Federal Court is not automatic," he explained, but it is now "common practice". What is more, "the practice has been that the apex court would normally grant the leave when the issue at hand involves novel and crucial legal or a constitutional question".

    A lawyer by profession and a member of the Central Committee of the Pan-Malaysian Islamic Party (PAS), Maidin rejects the arguments cited by the judges to justify their decision. Instead, he renews his support for and solidarity to the Catholic Church and the Christian community in Malaysia, which is going through a delicate moment in its history. In fact, Malaysia's Christian community has been the recent target of attacks, including church burning, the desecration of Christian graves and the seizure of 300 Bibles in January.

    The clash over the use of the word Allah to describe the Christian God is at the root of the violence. Indeed, what started out as a legal battle between the federal government and the Catholic weekly The Herald has now become a national controversy. 

    On 23 June, the High Court dismissed the request for the leave to appeal made by the Catholic weekly. However, the lawyer has no doubts that the issue raised by The Herald "met all the legal prerequisites for leave because it raised a very important constitutional issue, namely the correct interpretation of Article 11 of the Federal Constitution.

    The fact that seven Federal Court judges heard the leave application spoke volumes of the significance of the appeal. Yet, the leave was simply denied.

    Now the Muslim lawmaker is wondering about the "actual meaning of religious freedom" in the country because "even though Allah has been used by many non-Muslims throughout the world," a Malaysian court decided that in Malaysia, "freedom of religion excludes non-Muslims from using this sacred word."

    "Was this the actual meaning of freedom of religion envisaged by Islam or by our forefathers who drafted the Constitution?" he asks.

    The Herald never violated any constitutional rights, yet for Mohamed Hanipa Maidin the Federal Court "abdicated its solemn duty to protect the right of David against the mighty Goliath". 

    Citing the teachings of the great Muslim sage Ibnu Qayyim Al Jauziyyah, he said that "Islam is all about justice, mercy and wisdom . . . anything which transgresses the principle of justice or mercy or wisdom has nothing to do with Islam."

    In Malaysia, Muslim are 60 per cent of the more than 28 million people, Christians are the third largest religious group (after Buddhists) with more than 2.6 million members. 

    The publication of a Latin-Malay 400 year ago shows that the term Allah was already in use to describe God in the Bible in the local language.

    In Kuala Lumpur, out of a population of over 11 million people, Catholics number more than 180,000 with 55 priests and 154 religious, but only one permanent deacon.



    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    22/12/2014 MALAYSIA
    Kuala Lumpur, religious leaders: Dialogue, the basis of coexistence between different faiths
    Christians, Muslims and Buddhists gathered at a conference highlight the importance of dialogue and mutual understanding. Archbishop of Kuala Lumpur: "It does not mean “giving up one's faith”, but "understanding the sensitivities of others." Indonesian Muslim scholar: tolerance and pluralism basis of dialogue.

    28/04/2005 MALAYSIA
    Two Christians arrested for 'proselytising'
    Former Premier Mahatir denies a fundamentalist threat exists in the country.

    22/08/2016 10:13:00 MALAYSIA
    Kuala Lumpur, arrests famous rapper: "He insulted Islam"

    Namewee, stage name of Wee Meng Chee, was stopped at the airport in the capital yesterday after returning from a trip abroad. In the song "Oh My God" he used the word "Allah" and sounds similar to the Islamic call to prayer. The singer: "I did not mean to offend anyone but promote harmony between religions".

    21/02/2014 MALAYSIA - ISLAM
    Allah affair and the attack on the religious freedom do not bring votes to Malaysian government
    This is the result of a recent survey by UMCEDEL, based on a sample of about 10 per cent of the electorate in Kajang constituency where a by-election is scheduled next month pitting the ruling coalition against the opposition. For months, the government has wooed the Islamist vote. Anwar Ibrahim sides with freedom of worship for Christians.

    08/01/2010 MALAYSIA
    Malaysia: Four Christian churches attacked over controversy on the use of "Allah"
    Three Protestant places of worship, and one Catholic in the sights of Islamic fundamentalists. The offices of Metro Tabernacle Church damaged. Cars owned by Catholics vandalised. The director of the Catholic weekly Herald confirms "pressure" on government and judiciary to "cancel the Supreme Court ruling."

    Editor's choices

    North Korea will send a high-level Olympic delegation to Pyeongchang

    After two years of tensions, the first meeting between delegations from North and South Korea. Seoul proposes that North and South athletes march side by side in the opening and closing ceremonies of the Games (February 9-25, 2018).

    Pope: respect for the rights of persons and nations essential for peace

    In his address to diplomats, Francis asks for the solution to conflicts - starting with Syria - and tensions - from Korea to Ukraine, Yemen, South Sudan and Venezuela - and augurs that migrants and the "discarded" be welcomed, like unborn children and the elderly and respect for freedom of religion and opinion, the right to work.


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSSRSS channel 


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®