27 October 2016
AsiaNews.it Twitter AsiaNews.it Facebook
Geographic areas

  • > Africa
  • > Central Asia
  • > Europe
  • > Middle East
  • > Nord America
  • > North Asia
  • > South Asia
  • > South East Asia
  • > South West Asia
  • > Sud America
  • > East Asia

  • mediazioni e arbitrati, risoluzione alternativa delle controversie e servizi di mediazione e arbitrato

    » 08/09/2014, 00.00


    Russian-Ukrainian tensions slide towards religious intolerance

    Vladimir Rozanskij

    Priests and faithful of the different Churches are attacked by pro-Russian or pro-Ukrainian groups. The Greek-catholic accused of fomenting Ukrainian separatism. The religious and political hegemonic aims of the Patriarchate and Moscow.

    Moscow (AsiaNews) - One of the most insidious and difficult to understand aspects of the conflict in Ukraine, which has lasted for many months, is the religious intolerance of the parties involved, which has recently resulted in serious incidents of violence and intimidation against the faithful and religious themselves. The current leader of the Metropolia of Kiev, bishop Onufrij (Berezovsky), expressed his outrage in recent days following unspeakable actions carried out by military government troops in the Ukrainian Donbass, in the province of Donetsk, in the district of Amvrosiev and other "hotbeds" in the country.

    Since the very beginning of the Majdan riots, Onufrij - who has been in charge of the Ukrainian Metropolian see loyal to Moscow for several months, because of illness and death of Metropolitan Vladimir (Sabodan) - to avoid the confessional differences becoming weapons of war.  Yet his statements seem to voice the defeat of the ecclesiastical hierarchy, which has been forced to take sides between the warring parties. Even Greek-catholic hierarchies have begun to raise their voices in defence of their trampled upon rights.

    Religious differences

    Considering the particular fragmentation of the Ukrainian religious milieu, the distance taken by the individual Churches during of the most acute phases of the upheaval seemed like a miracle. The effort to maintain balance and mutual respect, despite the difficulty of bridging an incurable distrust, has thus far been undertaken and shared by all members of the clergy and of the nations' spiritual leaders. The religious background of the conflict in Ukraine is deeply imbedded, precisely because it has always developed the very identity of the various factions of the Ukrainian people; the inhabitants of the country are not separated by race - belonging as they do to the peoples of the "Great Russia" be they in Moscow, Kiev or Minsk - nor by language, which ranges from contiguity to Polish an Russian and Turkish-Caucasian dialects, but is actually the same for everyone. The linguistic motivations in favor of Russian or Ukrainian, which were used as formal reasons for the various local revolts, in truth hid the only real reason for the divisions: Religious differences. The Ukrainians are divided into pro-Russian Orthodox, Orthodox Ukrainian nationalists, Catholic "Uniates" and Latin-rite Catholics, and the war of religion has always developed among these denominations of the one Christian religion, given the fact that as a people they have always been very refractory to other denominations, including Protestantism; the Jews, who in the last century formed a rather significant community, were literally removed, forming the original base of the new state of Israel after World War II, so anti-Semitism is not a part of this entire feud that is internal to Christianity.

    The "day of reckoning" after the USSR

    The recent episodes of intolerance, moreover, closely resemble and are related to those of twenty years ago, when the collapse of the USSR in 1991 caused an immediate "showdown" between the Christians: The Orthodox Church split into several parts: the Greek-catholics came out of hiding to re-take, often by force, churches confiscated under Stalin, even among Uniate and Latin Catholics there were moments of great tension. The parishes and churches, the few remaining from Soviet times and the many recently rebuilt, are a constant source of contention, depending on the changing orientation of the priests and their faithful, whose families are often made ​​up of members belonging to different confessional and ecclesiastical realities. The propaganda of both sides, material or spiritual advantages, and today unfortunately, weapons, are tipping the scales in different directions each day, in a frenzied search for identity, which also plagues Ukrainian politics.

    Moscow's claims

    Beyond all ideological, historical and theological motivations, lies the great claim of the Moscow Patriarchate, which since the collapse of the Soviet empire has reiterated the theory of the "integrity of canonical territory", in short, the power of Moscow's jurisdiction over all Orthodox faithful of the ex-Soviet republics, including Ukraine. The question has actually been ongoing for centuries, when Moscow proclaimed patriarchal autocephaly in the late sixteenth century, and at the same time many Ukrainian diocese joined the Union with the Pope of Rome. The two different interpretations of Christianity by Russia and Ukraine, the Russian-centric and the Roman-centric, have generated endless and unresolved conflicts have, now compounded by the national autonomist variant, in reaction to Soviet imperialist oppression. It is no small coincidence that Moscow almost immediately laid the blame at the door of the Greek-Catholics, accusing them of being the instigators of the Majdan revolt, using the infamous appellative of banderovtsy, followers of Stepan Bandera, the duplicitous politician during the conflict between the Soviets and the Nazis , who was Greek-Catholic. The Vatican, in turn has been accused by Moscow of being unable to control the Uniates, is in obvious difficulty and does not know which path to take the confessional or ecumenical.

    The chickens are coming home to roost, and even if the Ukrainian military and political puzzle is ever solved, the question of "canonical territory" of the "Russian world" as Putin himself calls it, will remain: it is the last religious war of Europe's Christians before they disappear altogether from the "old continent" and give in to the cynical indifference of the West, a mankind without roots. In Russian lands people are still fighting for the Gospel, over who should represent it in today's world (and not just in Ukraine).



    e-mail this to a friend Printable version

    See also

    08/08/2016 15:33:00 RUSSIA – UKRAINE – VATICAN
    Moscow Patriarchate: "Uniates" too aggressive, threaten dialogue with the Catholic Church

    The Russian Orthodox Church slams the "politicised" attitudes of Ukraine’s Greek Catholic leaders following criticism by the archbishop of Kyiv, Sviatoslav Shevchuk, against the all-Ukrainian procession organised in July by the Ukrainian Orthodox Church.

    07/03/2016 18:28:00 VATICAN – UKRAINE
    Pope expresses “deep gratitude for the loyalty” of the Ukrainian Church, which remembers its martyrdom

    In a message on the anniversary of pseudo-synod of Lviv, when Stalin forced Ukrainian Catholics “back” into the fold of the Moscow Patriarchate, Francis expressed gratitude for “those that, in the course of time and at the price of tribulations and even of martyrdom, witnessed the faith”. He also renewed his “solidarity to the pastors and faithful for what they do in this difficult time, marked by the tribulations of the war, to alleviate the suffering of the population and to seek ways of peace for the dear Ukrainian land.”

    15/02/2016 09:48:00 UKRAINE-VATICAN-RUSSIA
    Ukrainian Greek Catholics: "betrayed" by "half-truths" in Francis and Kirill’s Joint Declaration

    The major archbishop of Kiev speaks of Cuba encounter: a meeting of "two parallel worlds". The Joint Declaration "generally positive" for future cooperation. Points which concern Ukraine “controversial”: the Vatican is being exploited by Russian Orthodox diplomacy. Shevchuk reiterates: the Greek-Catholic Church has never supported the war, provoked by "Russian aggression".

    24/02/2015 UKRAINE - RUSSIA
    Ukraine, a land scorched by history
    The end of the Soviet Union led to idea that the West and democracy had won. However, the Ukrainian conflict proves otherwise. Although the pope's words on post-communist economic injustices are right, they have boosted Russians' belief that they are the "last bastion" against the ruin that Western capitalism will inevitably inflict. For them, their apocalyptic fate is inexorably tied to what will happen on the Ukrainian border.

    19/06/2014 RUSSIA - UKRAINE
    Kyiv Greek Catholic archbishop tells "Orthodox brothers" not to believe propaganda, look at the truth
    Through AsiaNews Mgr Sviatoslav Shevchuk makes an appeal for reconciliation, following Moscow Patriarchate's attacks. "It is time to recognise the dignity of the Ukrainian people and Church."

    Editor's choices

    The new bishop of Changzhi and the many voices on China-Vatican dialogue

    Bernardo Cervellera

    The ordination will take place on November 10 in the Cathedral. The bishop had been appointed by the Holy See at least two years ago. But he was waiting for the green light from Beijing. Similar situation in Chengdu. Fears for the presence of excommunicated bishops. Reconciliation between illegitimate and official bishops is not brought about by political gestures, but depends on personal and canonical procedures. A meeting between the Chinese delegation and the Vatican is not "imminent".


    Pope: the cruelty of those who kill children in Iraq “makes us weep”

    "Our hearts are shocked by the heinous acts of violence that have been committed for far too long against innocent citizens, be they Muslim, Christian or members of other ethnic groups and religions."  World Mission Day “is time of courage”.


    AsiaNews monthly magazine (in Italian) is free.


    News feed

    Canale RSScanale RSS 

    Add to Google


    IRAN 2016 Banner

    2003 © All rights reserved - AsiaNews C.F. e P.Iva: 00889190153 - GLACOM®