09/17/2011, 00.00
Send to a friend

Assassination of Shahbaz Bhatti: new falsehoods from the police

by Jibran Khan
The two suspects would be former Christians converted to Islam, in conflict with the Bhatti family over some property. The Bishop of Islamabad: "The statement by the police is absurd." Christian and Muslim personalities decry a cover-up and demand a new inquiry commission.
Islamabad (AsiaNews) – Pakistani police are spreading new falsehoods and new doubts about the assassination of Shahbaz Bhatti, the Catholic Minister for Minorities, killed last March 2 by a group of Muslim extremists. Bhatti had long led a fight against the death sentence of Asia Bibi for blasphemy and in defense of religious minorities in his country.

According to the police in Islamabad, the two suspects in the killing, Zia-ur-Rehman and Malik Abid, would be two ex-Christians from Faisalabad, converted to Islam, who allegedly have a property dispute with the Bhatti family. The police have also stated that there is no evidence against them.

This is the second time that police have attempted what is being called a "cover-up". In August, some Pakistani media reported police statements according to which Shahbaz Bhatti would have been killed over "family disputes" related to some property (see 09/08/2011 Smoke screen and false news to hide Shahbaz Bhatti's assassins).

Later, the Court of Counterterrorism issued an international arrest warrant against Zia-ur-Rehman and Malik Abid, who after the assassination would have fled to Dubai (09/02/2011 Islamabad, Bhatti murder: focusing again on Islamic extemism).

In recent days, the two have been transferred to Pakistan, thanks to Interpol. The Senior Superintendent of Police Operations and the head of the Joint Investigation Team (JIT), however, said that "the suspects are being detained for investigating, they both were allegedly nominated by the Bhatti family, yet it would be too early to comment on their involvement in Bhatti's assassination as there is no evidence available about their involvement. They are being detained on the basis of doubt, things will get clear once they are interrogated."

The statements of the police provoked strong reactions and criticism in the Church of Pakistan. Mons. Rufin Anthony, Bishop of Islamabad and a personal friend of Shahbaz Bhatti told AsiaNews that "the statement by the police is totally absurd."

"If they are not sure about the involvement of the suspects", he added, "then what are they suspecting them for? Why did the court issue the warrants if the JIT didn't have any evidence about their involvement?"

For the bishop, there is a suspicion that "the police are defending the culprits, or diverting the direction of the case, arresting some so-called suspects and then gets them released, on the basis of the non-availability of solid evidence for their involvement”. "It is clear", he continued, "that if there is no evidence against the two suspects, they will be released by the court."

To Mons. Anthony, it is urgent to set up a serious inquiry committee. "It is about time that the concerned authorities start taking things seriously: as Shahbaz Bhatti's assassination is not only the assassination of a Federal Minister, it is the assassination of the voice of the voiceless. They have silenced a man, but can never silence his vision, his thoughts and his struggle for the marginalized".

The prelate's opinion is also shared by Muslim personalities. An academic Muslim cleric, Maulana Mahfooz Khan, also comments on the police statements: "They are just to divert the direction of the case. How can a vehicle [that of the murderers] disappear from the Federal Capital, where there are security checkpoints on all the entry and exits? Every citizen is stopped and questioned at every security checkpoint, how can a vehicle filled with armed men escape un-noticed by the authorities?"
Mahfooz Khan agrees that a new judicial commission is urgent. "The Government", he adds, "seems reluctant in taking interest in the assassination of their own Federal Minister, who was slain in broad daylight in Islamabad."

"Shahbaz Bhatti", he concludes, "fought for the rights of minorities; his struggle for the interfaith harmony is remarkable."
Send to a friend
Printable version
See also
"We are optimistic," says Paul Bhatti as Rimsha Masih's bail hearing postponed to Friday
Mgr Saldanha: Pope's words comfort Christians still in shock over Bhatti murder
Politicians, Christian leaders and thousands of people at the funeral for Shahbaz Bhatti
Assassination of Shahbaz Bhatti: three days of mourning, Pakistani Church on strike
Police try to downplay murder of Shahbaz Batthi. Fears for Asia Bibi


Subscribe to Asia News updates or change your preferences

Subscribe now
“L’Asia: ecco il nostro comune compito per il terzo millennio!” - Giovanni Paolo II, da “Alzatevi, andiamo”