21 November, 2009 A A A | | |
Help AsiaNews | About us | P.I.M.E. |
go to front page




Voli Low Cost Roma
Voli Milano



China | Islam | Economy | Freedom of religion | Vatican
e-mail this to a friend printable version


» 06/16/2006 13:01
INDIA
References to ancient Hindus' beef-eating past deleted from school textbooks
Hindu fundamentalists succeed after three years of disinformation campaign to have offensive chapters deleted from history textbooks that told how ancient Hindus considered beef a great delicacy. For historians, deleting pans of history is an error that eliminates a page of actual history.

Kolkata (AsiaNews/SCMP) – Any references to the beef-eating past of ancient Hindus have finally been deleted from Indian school textbooks, after a three-year campaign by religious hardliners.

For almost a century history books for primary and middle schools told how in ancient India beef was considered a great delicacy among Hindus—especially among the highest caste—and how veal was offered to Hindu deities during special rituals.

The offending chapters have been deleted from new versions of the books which were delivered to schoolchildren last week. However, the National Council of Educational Research and Training [NCERT], which bears responsibility for the texts, now seems to be unhappy with the changes, which were agreed to by a former NCERT director.

NCERT counsel Prashant Bhushan said that ancient Hindus were indeed beef-eaters and the council should not have distorted historical facts by deleting the chapters.

 "NCERT has committed a mistake by dropping those facts from the textbooks. It is a victory for Hindu fundamentalists who have lodged a misinformation campaign. Historians should unite against this cowardice by the council [NCERT]," said noted Kolkata historian Ashish Bos.

But hard-line Hindu activists, who consider cattle holy and have been seeking a ban on their slaughter by Muslims and Christians, said the beef-eating references were aimed only at insulting Hindus.

In 2003, when the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party [BJP] held federal power, Jagmohan Singh Rajput, then NCERT director, decided to delete the references. The process, however, took longer than expected.

Hindu fundamentalists last year alleged NCERT was dragging its feet in implementing the decision, and two activists filed public interest litigation with the Delhi High Court seeking the chapters' immediate deletion.

"Some low-caste Dalit [untouchable] Hindus used to eat beef [but] Brahmins [high caste Hindus] never ate it. Mr Sharma [Ram Sharan Sharma, author of the textbook chapters] had not researched well before writing the piece," said firebrand Hindu leader Praveen Togadia.

"The chapter is poisoning the minds of little [Hindu] children. They will not respect their own religion in future. They will not turn out to be good Hindus and it will cause harm to the nation," Mr Togadia said.


e-mail this to a friend printable version

See also
02/03/2006 INDIA
Strike in Mumbai and New Delhi airports as modernisation approaches
07/02/2009 INDIA
For Indian Church homosexuality is not a crime but cannot become a “social norm”
by Nirmala Carvalho
05/12/2009 INDIA
Uncertainty over the out come of Indian elections
by CT Nilesh
06/16/2006 SOUTH KOREA
Christian groups claim right to manage their own schools
07/17/2007 INDIA
New Delhi not to allow single states to define religious minorities


Dossier

Editor's choices
CHINA - VATICAN
Underground bishop: I joined the Patriotic Association for the good of the Church
by Zhen Yuan
Mgr. An Shuxin says he was not pressured by the Vatican for his choice. In front of the division created in the diocese of Baoding, priests and experts are asking the Vatican and China to free the ordinary Bishop Su Zhimin, , in prison for the past 13 years.
PAKISTAN - EU
Blasphemy in Pakistan and the European Court’s attack on the crucifix
by Bernardo Cervellera
Launched today from Rome the European leg (France, Holland, Belgium, Germany) of a campaign to raise awareness in Church and society of the plight and oppression of minorities in Pakistan, particularly the Christian one, due to the blasphemy law. A most unusual unity of purpose joins Islamic fundamentalists and European relativists.
CHINA – VATICAN
In Hebei, underground bishop joins Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association
by Bernardo Cervellera
Mgr Francis An Shuxin spent ten years in police custody. Now he is free but still under surveillance, dragged around to meetings to show the correctness of the government’s religious policy. Three bishops remain in police custody. A priest is arrested whilst two are freed to join the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association. The Vatican is accused of ambiguities.

Copyright © 2003 AsiaNews C.F. 00889190153 All rights reserved. Content on this site is made available for personal, non-commercial use only. You may not reproduce, republish, sell or otherwise distribute the content or any modified or altered versions of it without the express written permission of the editor. Photos on AsiaNews.it are largely taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to their publication need only contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the photos.